While I don't intentionally punish my c9 like Iraqvet did even I was surprised how well it held up.
I bought my c9 for a couple reasons.
1. I live in Ohio and thought it would be cool to have a gun made in Ohio
2. I wanted to see if all the bashing was justified.. short answer it was'nt.
3. It was cheap as sin.. 120 NIB, I was able to support my LGS and a homestate gun MFG So that felt good.
.. I also bought the 995 carbine (planet of the apes version "classic") both guns out the door for like 301, No regrets at this price.
I will probably pick up the 45acp carbine in the future (wasn't out when I bought mine)
My carbine has been 100% reliable and frankly a very fun gun to shoot.
My C9 had a lot jams the first 200-250 rounds, after that it got better.
I will say that I noticed more problems loading to 8 rounds rather than 7, I believe the magazines are the actual source of most problems people have.
The gun is obviously made cheaply but it is very durable, I do carry mine in a fobus holster, which actually fit it rather well and I recommend.
I carry it when Im doing dirty jobs, working in the yard, on the house, on the car.. I have no 2nd thoughts of simply rolling around in dirt and gravel bare gun to ground.
The powder coat finish on the slide while utilitarian is very tough.
My motto concerning the gun is "I carry it like I hate it"
Take down is a PITA cause of the use of a punch that is no lie, I usually just wipe mine down based on what I can see/get to.
I think HP's own advice is like every 500 rounds or something.
The slide fitment is fairly loose so regular cleaning isn't critical anyway.
Despite the funky look I find it fits my hand rather well ergonomically.
I am impressed with the simplicity of the design, The sights are actually quite nice and adjustable and better then you'd hope for on a cheap pistol.
My gun was horribly off when I first got it (hardly on paper at 25ft), the first range trip I had to result to point shooting since I did'nt have any tools for adjustment and it did rather well so it points very nicely (at last for me, again ergonomics)
I do not know where they source their barrel material, I do remember reading a interview with the owner years ago that they had a lot of automotive supply companies in the area that they utilize for parts like the zamak cast slide.. so it could be true.
I do know it's +p rated so it can't be all that bad.
While I've not had a need to contract HP for CS I've yet to hear about bad service and some of the stories I've heard has me convinced the no questions asked is beyond real and I have little doubt they have the best CS in the industry.
Most of what you hear negative about HP is from people who have not even shot a HP let alone owned one, Generally you'll get a lot of parrots feeding parrots or people judging on looks or price.
If you can get one for 150 I say do it, see for your self (assuming you can afford 150 to blow on a lark) Chances are you'll see that while the gun is not perfect most of the bashing is just that.. bashing.
I would not pay more then 150 even knowing what I know however.
It is a bit bulky for a 8 shot single stack at the end of the day.
By no means is the c9 my first choice, But as far as what it is and what it sells for it's pretty much the Cadillac of cheap guns.