Hey guys, new here - A bit overwhelming with so many options!

I'm not going to give a long mile long post....

First, 9mm is a great round. Great caliber choice. In a full size semi-auto the only other caliber I'd consider is .45acp but I prefer the easy control and higher mag capacity of 9mm.

Second, the glock is a good gun. However, I suggest you try a couple of its' main competitors. The Springfield Armory XD and the Smith and Wesson M&P. I find that both are more comfortable to shoot. Both have higher magazine capacity. Also, the ergonomics are far better on both. Reliabilty is excellent on all three. They are all on par with each other in terms of quality. I just think you'll like one of the other two better, most do that try them.

Good luck.
 
<<Safety? On a standard double/single action semi-auto there is no need for a safety.>>

All those with Glock Leg sure could have used a safety........

Regardless,

If YOU are more comfortable with a safety and if YOU decide that for YOU the advantages of a safety outweigh the disadvantages, then by all means buy a pistol with a safety.

Standard double/single actions semi-autos are built and sold with safeties because some people prefer and/or need them.
 
Wow, LOTS of good advice here. I really appreciate it guys. Thanks for everyone taking the time out to respond to my thread.

I just got back from the local shooting center, and I rented a Glock 19. That was the only gun they had for whatever reason. I'll post up a picture of my sheet. I did fairly well if you ask me.

Initial thoughts: It felt very nice. Extremely solid and beefy. Fired nicely, felt extremely powerful. It definitely took some time getting used to however. I've NEVER shot a gun before, so I wasn't sure of what to expect. The first couple shots, my wrist were moving around a lot. Since I felt it a bit more, I got a LOT better. That thing has a lot of recoil. My girl was unable to even shoot the gun. She shot twice and both bullets didn't leave the chamber. Completely brought her arms up in the air. It felt really good to me once I got to shooting it, but obviously not for my girl. She got scared after the first two shots and didn't want to do it anymore. I had a BLAST though! Lotta lotta fun shooting that thing.

They had a brand new Ruger P95 in the store for $350, which I think was really good. I'm going to a local gun show tomorrow to see how much some of the guns there will be. Should be fun.

Anyway, thanks for the advice guys! Keep it coming!
 
There are many things that you need to consider.

First, 9mm is a fine cartridge for self-defense. At one time, it's reputation was not so good, but that was mainly because of the ammunition available at the time (FMJ or primative JHP's). So long as you stick with a modern JHP from a reputable manufacturer, 9mm is a perfectly sound choice. Examples of good loadings include Speer Gold Dot, Winchester Supreme SXT, Winchester Ranger, Remington Golden Saber, Federal HST, and Federal Hydra-Shok.

While 9mm is a good cartridge, it is not the only good one. .357 Sig, .40 S&W, .38 Special, .357 Magnum, and .45 ACP are also excellent choices which are relatively common and should be available at most respectable gun shops. Other cartridges like 10mm Auto and .44 Special are good, but they may not be as available as the others I've mentioned.

The next issue is that of semi-automatic vs. revolver as both have advantages and disadvantages. A revolver's main advantages are simplicity, better size-to-power ratio, and less sucseptability to common malfunctions relating to ammunition or improper grip. A semi-automatic, on the other hand, will usually offer higher capacity, faster reloads, and less recoil for a given power cartridge. Also some find the single-action trigger of a semi-auto to be easier to master than the double-action trigger of most self-defense revolvers. I do, however, note that the DA trigger of a revolver is typically better than the DA trigger of most autos.

Finally, I'll address the Glock in particular since you mentioned that brand specifically. A Glock is a fine weapon and one would be well armed with such, but they aren't the be-all, end-all that some make them out to be. There are some features that prevent a Glock from being the right choice for everyone.

First and foremost, we have the Glock's trigger and safety mechanisms. While a Glock is legally defined as a double-action-only handgun and has numerous safety features, it still has a relatively short and light trigger pull and all the safety features are passive. The Glock's trigger is defined as DAO because the striker is only partially cocked until the trigger is pulled. However, the weight and length of a Glock's trigger is much more similar to a SA trigger like that of a 1911 or Browning Hi-Power than it is to a more traditional DA trigger like that of a Beretta M92, S&W metal-frame auto, Sig, or revolver. Also, unlike many SA autos, the Glock's only safety features are passive, meaning that no conscious effort beyond depressing the trigger is required to deactivate them. The only purpose that a Glock's safety really serves is to ensure that the pistol will not inadvertently discharge if dropped.

Secondly, the polygonal rifling of a Glock's barrel require jacketed bullets while conventionally rifled barrels are compatable with both jacketed and cast lead bullets. While most 9mm ammo uses jacketed bullets anyway, there is some out there with cast bullets. If you wish to use cast bullets in your Glock, you need to buy an aftermarket barrel such as those available from Lone Wolf.

Finally, while a Glock's polymer frame does significantly reduce weight, reduced weight usually makes recoil more pronounced. A heavier, all-steel gun will typically have less recoil than a lighter aluminum-alloy or polymer gun.

I am not trying to discourage you from buying a Glock, they are the perfect choice for some people. I am, however, trying to help you make an educated decision. I would encourage you to research and handle (shoot if possible) as many different handguns as you can before making a decision. At the end of the day, it's really a very personal thing.
 
Webleymkv: Thanks for the long, detailed response. While at the range today, I did notice that the Glock 19 had quite a bit recoil. I've never shot anything else, so I don't have anything else to compare it too, but the guy at the shop did mention that the Ruger P95 would have much less pronounced recoil, making that a big plus to me and my fiance'. She couldn't handle the glock 19 at all, so that gun is out of the race. I'm hoping I can find somewhere that will let me fire off a Ruger P95, as I'm very interested in it. I handled it quite a bit at the shop today and it felt very nice. Also held a Taurus PT 111 millenium pro and that felt great as well. Tough choices here, as my options are a bit limited, but I'm going to continue to do my research before buying anything. There's a local gun show tomorrow that I hope to attend. Perhaps I'll get some more hands on experience on several different hand guns.
 
AdrianVall - I applaud you for being somewhat patient and not jumping into a purchase just to get a new toy. You can get a lot of good information at a gun show and they are fun to browse. Take a pad of paper to the show with you to make some notes on what you like and price ranges. You can get some serious gun overload at a gun show so making some notes may come in real handy.

The real purpose of this response is to address your girl friend, or maybe fiance. Many young women grow up without being exposed to or having any interest in firearms. They then get dragged into shooting with a boy friend who hands them a hand cannon and laughs their rear end off when the barrel makes a dent in the girls forehead. If you doubt me, just search on girls and guns on Youtube. What I would suggest is introduce your girlfriend to shooting with something she is not intimidated by. Let her get the basics of safety, proper handling and shooting stance with a target .22 rimfire. The noise is far less and recoil is non existent. My wife had never handled a firearm of any type before we met so I bought her a .357 revolver and tried to teach her myself. Well, she did just fine with mild .38 special target loads, but I would have done things a lot differently had I not wanted that .357 myself. :D

Seriously, you both should learn to shoot but what works for you may not work for her. If your local range doesn't have a larger .22 target pistol to rent, maybe they can refer you to someplace that does. You really want her to build confidence with a gun and caliber she will be comfortable with.

Whatever you do have fun tomorrow at the show and learn all you can. As always come back here to let us know what you think.
 
AdrianVall, if you intend for your girl friend to use the gun too, you're definately on the right track in having her try the guns you're considering. One model that you might want to look at it the CZ-75B. I reccomend this model because I've had several women try mine and all of them seemed to like it very well. The grip of a CZ will be comfortable to most people and its all steel frame, and thusly heavier weight, go a long way towards soaking up recoil. While the Ruger P95 is an excellent gun, make sure your GF tries it before you buy one as they have a rather fat grip and don't fit many smaller-handed people.
 
First off let me just say welcome AdrianVall. Nice to have another fellow Floridian in the mix. While the "perfect" gun for you will ultimately be your choice let me just say you cannot go wrong with a Ruger P95 9mm.
 
The CZ's are pretty popular. I do like Glocks. I have a couple 40 S&W's and I like the Model 23 the best. I describe the recoil as snappy with the Glocks I have shot. It isn't bad and something you should just get used to. Both 9mm and 40 S&W ammo is pretty reasonable as ammo goes these days. The Glock M23 is one of my home defense handguns that I keep loaded. I don't try to conceal it as I have the little revolver mentioned below.

If I took any of my handguns into "combat".... let's say a post-hurricane situation such as Katrina, I would choose a Glock. No Question. They are tough and shoot pretty much flawlessly. You can't go wrong with one unless it just doesn't feel right in your hand. One of the nice things about Glocks in the same caliber is that the magazines fit any of the models. So you can have 10 rounders and 14-15 rounders around and they will all fit in a pinch. This is one of the reasons the Homeland Security folks use Glocks.

I carry a small revolver, S&W M442 for concealed carry. This is a 38spl revolver. I suspect you'd think the Glock recoil was nothing compared to one of light little revolvers. I don't recommend one for general range shooting. They are for business mostly for me. No other reason I'd want to even shoot it.

A great gun for home defense is a 4" Ruger GP100 revolver (357 mag or 38spl). But you said you preferred a pistol to a revolver. No problem.

If you want to learn to shoot, I highly recommend getting a 22 revolver or pistol. The semi-auto pistols are relatively inexpensive and I like the Ruger Mark III with the 5.5" bull barrel the best. Your girl friend should probably enjoy shooting one of these as there is essentially no recoil. The Browning Buckmark is my other favorite. My X always kept one of my Colt Diamondbacks as her home defense gun... I lost that one. Oh well...
 
First, welcome!

This topic is a frequent one. If you search you'll find a lot of answers.

$300 is a tough entry point for a quality handgun. It's the absolute bottom of the pile for anything I would consider an quality defensive handgun. If you know what you want and spend time hunting, you might find a great deal on a used gun. But you have to put in the effort.

Here's my NO BS recommendation for a beginner on a budget.

Caliber: 9mm - affordable to shoot and available nearly everywhere. Practice is the most important thing for newbies and for pros. 9mm is also plenty powerful for reliable self defense if you remember that shot placement is more important than caliber size, provided the caliber can do the job. If you do your part, the 9mm will do the rest. And it's versatile enough to have it in a home defense gun and a carry gun.

Gun: In the $300-$400 range you can find a good used gun. I would personally look at Glocks, CZ 75 series, Ruger P series, Springfield XD series. To keep costs down, find a seller that will sell face to face. Make sure you know the laws. Go to a gunstore beforehand and handle the same gun you anticipate buying and ask them to show you how to break it down. When you meet the seller, break it down and inspect the insides with a light to make sure it appears shiney and not rusty and there are no obvious cracks, damage, etc.
 
Back
Top