handgun ammo availability: 9mm vs. 40S&W

anonimoose

New member
Shooters,

The recent thread on the most common handgun in law enforcement got me thinking. One of the reasons why I insist on owning pistols chambered in 9x19mm is the availability of ammo -- it's cheap and plentiful, and I figure that in a true WROL situation, I'm more likely to have success if scrounging for 9x19mm.

But if it's true that the majority of law enforcement agencies use firearms chambered in .40S&W, aren't I more likely to find success hunting for that caliber?

I guess it matters where you live?

- NJ, CA, Chicago, DC and other non-gun-friendly areas -- few private firearms; most firearms in the hands of police, so the most plentiful handgun ammunition is probably .40S&W
- you're in the service and/or live close to a military base or station -- more likely to run across 9x19mm
- you live in a gun-friendly part of the country -- lots of private firearms; lots of different types of ammo floating around, could probably scrounge for whatever caliber floats your boat

Of course...I know how to fix the dilemma. Get both!

very respectfully,
Moose
 
I'm no expert, but it seems to me that .40 s&w has become a quite popular cartridge for both law enforcement and citizens alike. I don't imagine it would be a difficult cartridge to scrounge for.
 
9mm is vastly more popular throughout the world. Along with ultra common calibers like 7.62x39, you don't have to worry about it disappearing, regardless if used by US police or not.
 
I have noticed in NH that when supplies get low, 40 tends to be the last on the shelf. A couple years ago when amo was scarse, 40 was all I could find. Ended up getting a Glock23 because of that. Just something to think about.
 
If you're concerned about a WROL situation eliminate the possibility that you may find yourself "scrounging" for ammo. The simple solution is to stockpile 2k or whatever other number you feel is adequate for whatever might come up. I have a pretty large stockpile of 9, 40, 38, 357, 22 rimfire, 380 and .556 or .223 whichever you prefer calling it. I don't expect a WROL, it's just difficult to stop reloading once you get started.

I have considered stockpiling 50 gallons or so of drinking water and some MRE type food stuffs.
 
Also depends on the type of shop you go to, a local shop I go to every now and then that mainly caters to LEO's has a LOT and I mean a LOT of .40 S&W stuff, way more than any other caliber of ammo.

That being said, the other shop/range I go to that is mostly us civilians has more 9MM than .40 S&W.

Also if you go to a gunshop that gets lots of LEO trade in guns, I have found you see TONS of 45's, a smaller number of 9mm but almost no .40 S&W guns.


I am trying to refocus my collection on 9mm mainly because of the price, on a good day a box of 50 target type rounds costs me $10.00. If I want .40 S&W on a good day its $15.00.
 
Reload. Stockpile components. Brass can be reused. Have one or more revolvers on hand, the brass is easier to find after it is fired.
 
Battle rifle calibers are of primary interest to me for future Mad Max type scenarios, or govt regulations gone mad. Handguns are not the star players, although I'm not short of handgun ammo, either. :D
 
The fact that .40 was quite plentiful during the last 9mm scarcity in East TN prompted me to get a couple of .40s. I don't have a problem supporting three major calibers. .38, 9mm, and .40...and .22LR.
 
I don't buy much ammo but I do look around. I doubt you'll have much problem finding either 9 or 40 in this country.

Problem I have is 38s, not that its that uncommon but the ammo I want it hard to find. I like 38 LSWC in the standard loading, no hollow points, Try to find some of that stuff. It matches my SWCs I load and use in practice and competition.
 
Moose: said:
The recent thread on the most common handgun in law enforcement got me thinking. One of the reasons why I insist on owning pistols chambered in 9x19mm is the availability of ammo -- it's cheap and plentiful, and I figure that in a true WROL situation, I'm more likely to have success if scrounging for 9x19mm.

But if it's true that the majority of law enforcement agencies use firearms chambered in .40S&W, aren't I more likely to find success hunting for that caliber?

I guess it matters where you live?

- NJ, CA, Chicago, DC and other non-gun-friendly areas -- few private firearms; most firearms in the hands of police, so the most plentiful handgun ammunition is probably .40S&W
- you're in the service and/or live close to a military base or station -- more likely to run across 9x19mm
- you live in a gun-friendly part of the country -- lots of private firearms; lots of different types of ammo floating around, could probably scrounge for whatever caliber floats your boat

Of course...I know how to fix the dilemma. Get both!

Moose,

If you didn't notice or were fortunate enough to be somewhere where the 2008-2009 Obammoscare didn't result in an overnight run on all "cheap and plentiful" "service caliber" ammunition, do not fool yourself; .380Auto, .38 Special, .357 Magnum, .357 SIG, 9x19, .40 S&W, 10mm, .45 ACP and any other caliber that I've neglected to mention will disappear before you have the chance to "scrounge" it.

And that was when there was no real SHTF/WROL/TEOTWAWKI crisis driving it, folks just panicked and snatched it all up. And yes, I know what a "poop" Obama is when it comes to the Second Amendment. :D

When it comes to romanticized thoughts of, "Oh, I'll just scrounge ammo.", there are five rules that you'd do well to consider when you "come up against it":

1.) What you have in the way of ammunition before any real (or perceived) crisis begins is exactly what you'll have when it begins.

2.) Everyone else, and I mean everyone else, will be in the same situation as you meaning that they, too, planned to "scavenge, beg, borrow and scrounge" the exact same "cheap and plentiful" ammunition that you did, too. It is not an original idea. This means that you will not be able to just bee-bop on down to your local Walmart, Ma & Pa Gunshop, Cabela's or Gander Mountain and clear the shelves in order to "stock up". Those sources will be picked clean so fast that it'll make your head swim. Don't count on the "good nature" or the "espirit de corps" of your fellow gun owners to leave some ammuniton behind for you. They have families that they will put before everyone else. I couldn't blame them for it either since that is exactly what I'd be doing.

3.) It won't matter how many people have it [your caliber(s)] in their possesion, they won't be handing it out to those who have none or just got caught with their pants around their ankles. They will also be unable to replenish/replace their ammuntion being subject to the same conditons that you are and unless you are willing to pay exorbitant prices to obtain it (I often saw 50 round boxes of .380 Auto going for $90-$110 per box during the '08-'09 Obammo-scare and that was frequently on-line!), you won't be buying more until supply catches up with demand. That may be as short as days or as long as months.

4.) The idea of running across a miltary base or police station and obtaining 9mm (or any other ammunition for that matter) from them is ridiculous. They, too, will also be subject to the same market forces that you are and finding themselves in that situation will not be handing out ammunition to "the less fortunate" and "unprepared". They will need what little ammunition they have in their possession to execute their duties and that means that they won't be letting any of it go without a real good reason. Your failure to plan will not constitute an emergency on their behalf.

5.) If something truly horrendous comes to pass (a huge meteor strike obliterates 2/3rds of the North American Continent, a nuclear event/EMP strike, aliens arrive who see us only as a food stock, a biological disaster of biblical proportion, etc.) supply will likely never catch-up with demand and the only way you'll be scrounging or scavenging ammunition is by picking it from the bodies of the dead and dying or killing people for it. Nobody'll want to barter ammunition because it can be used against them afterwards to take what little they have unless they've just flat out given up. A post-catastrophic barter economy will be utterly ruthless. Count on it.

The moral of the story is Rule #1

Better have enough (can you actually predict how much you're going to need?) on hand, 'cause if/when the fecal matter hits the air circulating device it'll already be too late.

Good luck and Happy New Year! :D


ETA: Oh yeah, forgot to mention that I pray that it never comes to this.
 
Last edited:
Excellent .40 cal prices at sgammo.com make me think about getting one. You can sometimes find premium police Winchester Ranger-T HP loads there for prices very close to 9mm ball, which is pretty amazing.
 
A WROL situation?

That's an AM radio station in Boston. Have all y'all invented a new language? Is it a secret? :)
 
Yeah, I am trying to figure out WROL as well.

As for ammo variety is where it is at. During the last big scare I could always find something to shoot because I have a large variety of arms in different calibers. That being said .40 was one of the easier to find common calibers in our area.

Real world events such as disasters etc. you better have ammo, batteries, bourbon and toilet paper cuz you ain't going to find any of it and since real life is so incredibly far from fiction batteries, bourbon and TP come first for me. :D
 
johnbt said:
A WROL situation?

That's an AM radio station in Boston. Have all y'all invented a new language? Is it a secret?
Same question. I hate it when people use personal, secret acronyms. We're here to communicate, and that can't happen if we write in secret code.

What the heck is WROL? I've heard of WTSHTF and TEOTWAWKI, but ... WROL? I can't even guess what that might stand for. When Redheads Occupy Louisiana?
 
Back
Top