I don't think I've tried any tactical gloves. I did like the nomex flight crew gloves in Iraq when every friggin thing there was too hot to touch. Back home I tried some motor cycle gloves (deer skin) and found the padding too thick and the glove too cold in winter. Then I tried some mechanics gloves- either too tight or too loose and not enough in-between sizes. The weight lifting gloves seemed too thick in the palm. I bought a pair of fingerless wheelchair gloves at a pharmacy on a whim and love the things except they are crazy hard to get off once you've sweated in them a while. Oh, and one time I shot in blue rubber medical gloves just to make the other guys wonder if I'd finally gone off the deep end (really don't recommend those).