Exactly right
Del,
I agree with you about three hundred percent. In fact I have always thought that the pin design is a little on the "Rube Goldberg" side. I don't know if originals came with the pin. But had I been a manufacturer concerned with keeping the arbor tight and axially alligned I think I would have drilled all the way through from top to bottom and through the arbor. I would have driven the pin into the frame. With the hole drilled all the way through the frame, the pin could be driven out easily if necessary. I do acknowledge that drilling the frame as I have described might weaken the frame.
I doubt that the manufacturers were much worried about arbors coming loose. I think their attitude was probably more like, once the pistol is out the door, the government will assme full responsibility for dealing with the failures.
Here is a question for you historians:
Isn't it true that most of the brass frame revolvers that were copied from the Colt open top design, were made in the South and were made during the war, not before the war? Did Colt manufacture any brass frame pistols in the 1851 or 1860 pattern?