I have two El Paso Saddlery holsters. Both are very high quality and fit the intended gun properly. The first one had the proper size belt loops (based on what I specified in my order) and the snaps on the holster were one-way snaps which are very secure.
The second one had belt loops that were far too large for the belt size I specified and the snaps used were standard snaps rather than more secure one-way snaps. They don't specify the type of snaps used in their advertising, so I can't really complain about that, but it was irritating that the belt loops were improperly sized. I contacted them and told them about the belt loops being wrong. The belt-loop portion of the holster could be very easily removed so I figured they would send me the right size belt loop section and/or have me return the wrong one. Instead, they wanted me to send the entire holster back with no mention of them picking up the shipping.
Rather than pay to send the holster back, I figured out how to modify the belt loops myself. The result is not as good as it would be if they had sent me the right belt loop section, but it's good enough and it was a lot cheaper than having to ship it back to them.
The whole situation with the second holster left sort of a bad taste in my mouth.
That said, the holster has held up very well and it's been my primary carry holster for several years so I can't complain too much.