Here's a local article that the AP adapted:
http://www.savannahmorningnews.com/CURRENT/LOCaxed.shtml
Scout axed from school
Jenkins junior suspended for having knife, ax in car used for scouting activities.
By Jenel Few
Savannah Morning News
Brian Agnew is a Jenkins High School junior, Eagle Scout and honors student. And his parents couldn't be more proud.
He scored 1,000 on the SAT when he was in seventh grade, he's a member of the National Honor Society, is taking three Advanced Placement courses, plays the trumpet in the school band, leads a school group called Warriors for Christ, and he's a senior patrol leader for Boy Scout Troop 26 and recently completed his Eagle Scout project -- an outdoor trail at May Howard Elementary School.
But he also got suspended for having a knife, an ax and a cell phone in his car and has to finish out the school year at an alternative school as part of his punishment.
On May 9 while Brian was in first-period physics, he was called out of class and sent to the principal's office because the administration received an anonymous tip from someone who said he might have weapons in his car. Brian's parents say their son was set up.
"We think it was a student," his father, David Agnew, said. "We don't know if it was a jealousy thing or a grudge."
Brian admitted there was an ax locked in his trunk and agreed to a search of his car.
School officials found the ax head and the handle which, according to his father, had broken off some months earlier. David Agnew said his father had given it to him 20 years ago, and he passed it down to Brian. Brian kept it even after the handle broke off because it reminded him of his grandfather.
His father said the ax had been used a month earlier on his Eagle Scout project at May Howard and the night before at a Boy Scout meeting, where Brian demonstrated the proper handling of scouting tools.
In the glove box there was a pocketknife his father had purchased for him for advancing in scouting and a cell phone his father gave him for safety.
The ax, knife and cell phone are all banned from school property under the Savannah-Chatham County School System's "Student Code of Conduct."
Number two on the Code of Conduct's list of 10 Level I Misbehaviors is bringing nuisance and nonrelated items on school property -- including telephones and other electronic devices.
Sixth on the list of 10 acts that are punishable as a designated felony and warrant mandatory student referral to alternative school is using, exhibiting or possessing an illegal knife or club or any other prohibited weapon.
Ninth on the list of 19 behaviors warranting expulsion and referral to court is possession or use of any dangerous instrument which may be used to inflict bodily harm, including knives.
The Student Code of Conduct lists all of the school system's expectations and responsibilities for students and their parents, according to Pat Leslie, the system administrator who handles the 50-page document.
"It's given to students in the beginning of the year and it is given to their parents who have to sign for it," Leslie said. "We do that so they know the consequences and so they know exactly what the school rules are."
The consequences for Brian Agnew included an automatic 10-day suspension and transfer to alternative school from May 9-22.
That meant he was banned from regular campus activities and Jenkins High School. He missed the spring band concert, the National Honors Society Banquet, the Honors Night ceremony, the junior prom and two advanced placement exams, according to his father.
Then a hearing was held so an administrative panel could determine punishment for the possession of the ax and knife -- behaviors that typically warrant expulsion and criminal charges.
His parents hired an attorney and students and family friends testified about the clean-cut boy's stellar behavior and accomplishments. Many of David Agnew's colleagues who had never met his son joined the cause because they felt it was unfair to punish someone with such an upstanding reputation.
"We hoped the 10 days would be the end," his father said. "But they decided he would get long-term suspension and he can't come back to school until the fall."
Because the long-term suspension will extend through the summer, Brian Agnew won't be able to go to Washington, D.C., with the high school band and perform at a White House Bicentennial celebration. And they're concerned that he might not be able to attend the Governor's Honors program at Valdosta State this summer.
"My son has suffered enough. My family has suffered enough," David Agnew said. "My son is being offered as sacrifice on the altar of policy."
People, he said, are more important than policy.
"I knew he had the ax in the car. He knew he had the ax in the car. But I never considered it a weapon -- I considered it a tool," David Agnew said.
But should a school system that has had three campus shooting incidents and three student deaths in four years make exceptions to the zero tolerance weapons rules?
Just two months ago three students were shot in front of Beach High School after leaving a school dance. Two of them died. In 1996 a student was shot to death by a schoolmate on campus. Two months later a Groves High school student fired off two shots at students in the media center and attempted a third but his gun jammed.
In an era in which students throughout the country have chosen to settle their differences and express their frustrations with deadly campus violence, school officials say they can't afford to be flexible with their weapons policies. To exempt a student in possession of two banned weapons because he is a nice guy and didn't intend on hurting anyone could open up the door for too many other excuses for breaking rules.
"We have rules and regulations that are in print and we must abide by those guidelines," said Robert Gilbert, associate superintendent of schools.
Still, many of Agnew's supporters have gone to school administrators and board members to try to get the suspension rescinded.
They argue that there is a need for a zero tolerance policy, but not one that affects good kids. And Brian Agnew, they say, is a really good kid who is being made to suffer because of an inflexible, unforgiving policy.
"There's a fear and probably an overwhelming caution of these kinds of things but we have a choice to make and the board has a choice to make," said Skidaway Presbyterian Church Rev. Todd Collier. "Dictate decisions by fear or by sound reasoning based upon the facts of each case."
Collier only knows of the boy's reputation. But he said that was enough to compel him to speak to Jenkins High School Principal Freddie Gilyard.
"Here's a kid with no record of bad behavior or violence -- nothing but stellar performance. He's not walking around like some thug in the hallway," Collier said. "You can't lump them all in the same basket. You've got to handle case by case."
The boys' parents and supporters don't think the school system should have a predetermined list of crimes and punishments. They believe administrators should look past the infractions and consider a student's intent and past record before a punishment is determined.
"The only crime committed was that the better part of my son's junior year has been robbed from him," David Agnew said.
But School Police Chief Ulysses Bryant said board policy is separate from state law. Carrying an ax in your trunk and a knife in your glove compartment might not be illegal under state law, he said. But board policy prohibits it and if you bring those things on campus you will have to adhere to consequences it established to maintain order and safety.
If you're a box boy carrying a box cutter for work, if you have a steak knife in your lunch bag to cut up leftovers, even if you're an Eagle Scout with an ax and knife for scouting, Bryant said it will not be tolerated.
But David Agnew said he isn't ashamed of anything his son has done. "My son is not a criminal, he's not a villain. He's more than paid his due."
He is working with an attorney to plan an appeal to the school board.
"I told him I was so sorry a Boy Scout pocket knife I had given him for advancement in Boy Scouts and an ax I passed on to him was being used against him."
Higher education reporter Jenel Few can be reached at jfew@savannahnow.com or 652-0325.