Do You Know Any Vegetarians Who Hunt?

Do you know any hunters that are vegetarian?

  • No

    Votes: 59 80.8%
  • Yes - (percentage that you know, that are in a post)

    Votes: 12 16.4%
  • Not Sure

    Votes: 2 2.7%

  • Total voters
    73
  • Poll closed .
Some of the boffins say we are as intelligent as we are because we took to eating meat as our main source of protein. We collected meat by developing the smarts to hunt in co-operation with each other. There was no looking back. And apparently meat is 'brain-food' too. That type of protein advantage put us way ahead of what we might have been.
Wonder how many generations of vegetarianism would have us back to grunting at each other and swinging from trees?:)
Maybe that's the answer to global warming but it doesn't work for me.
 
Vegetarian but not by choice

Due to health issue`s in which he was born with, I`ve got a nephew(now fourteen) that has never had meat nor will he ever be able to have any. I started taking him hunting when he was about 9 and today he`s quite an outdoorsman with 4-5 deer and a very nice 11 3/4" bearded turkey to his credit. He understands that hunting is not about the kill and what his family doesn`t eat, the rest goes to a food pantry. This year he`s made us very proud cause he`s picked out a needy family and wants to shoot them a deer. Wish he could trade his deer for the $400-$450/mo. his special food cost:rolleyes:.
 
I was raised on all of it. Meat (store bought and wild game), and all forms of seafood... Fish (freshwater and inland saltwater), shrimp, crabs, crawfish and oysters. Aside from the oysters (I don't eat them anymore), I eat, and thoroughly enjoy, seafood and game (store-bought meat, also) to this day, and wouldn't have it any other way.

I Flat-Out Love It. If "they" Outlawed it, I'd be an Outlaw.

Others being Vegan is their way/life, and I don't have any problem with it, they don't effect me. It's people like those at PETA that tend to get under my fingernails... Don't hate me 'cuz I'm a Carnivore.
 
The no meat thing is more about factory farming than hunting. Free range animals or small boutique farms are much less damaging that the giant pig and beef factories. But of course they're lots more expensive so there would be a market based reduction in commercial meat consumption.
The main carbon cost of hunting is for the gas to get you there and back.
 
The no meat thing is more about factory farming than hunting. Free range animals or small boutique farms are much less damaging that the giant pig and beef factories.

Perhaps but there is no way to provide enough protein to our population through hunting. Factory farming produces huge numbers of large animals that would never exist otherwise in nature today. If the government tried to do away with factory farming people would starve and game animals would likely become extinct through poaching in a few years. In hypothetical scenario where meat outlawed I know I would hunt to feed my family
This year he`s made us very proud cause he`s picked out a needy family and wants to shoot them a deer.

Sounds like a great kid!
 
There's nothing better in the way of eating flesh than those Yellow Pike we filleted while they were still kicking and fried the fillets in a huge cast-iron frying pan over a driftwood fire, on a deserted beach in the remote wilderness of northern Quebec. The fresh air, clean water, and fresh fish dinner, followed by a frosty Molson's Canadian trumped all the broccoli you can find cooked any way you can think of. Oh, I like broccoli (and all other fruits and vegetables) just fine, they are delicious in their own way. But so is fresh fish, and when you can get it that fresh it's the best of all.

Or how about a doe or a spikehorn whitetail, taken early in the hunting week and butchered by my grandfather (a veterinarian) and cooked by a gormet Italian cook who used to be the chief chef for the wealthiest family in Italy before he came here and opened a restaurant that still exists and is 4-star rated 70 years later. Venison cacciatore, rump roasts, steaks, all done with European flair and using the stuff he brought in a mysterious box of cooking wine, cheeses, herbs and spices, cooked on a huge iron wood-burning stove in a log cabin with no utilities.

I'll be damned if I'm going to betray my ancestry and live without the stuff we're programmed to have- meat, sex, clean air, clean water, green things to walk among and eat, a dry warm place to sleep, community with family and friends- We are designed (by God or evolution, or both- that discussion is for elsewhere) to be omnivores- we eat everything, plant or animal, but in the proportions that the earliest humans found their food- lots of complex carbohydrates from the plants we foraged (and eventually grew ourselves), and once in a while 2 or 3 special days of meat when our hunting instincts and abilities provided one for food (which we eventually raised ourselves). We lived like that for a million years (or so). Show me a celibate vegetarian who lives alone and never leaves the city and I'll show you someone who's less than 1/3 a human. It's fine with me if that's how he or she wants to live, but it's NOT fine with me to try to make me live that way too, or to prevent me from living my life my way when doing so hurts no one. Yeah, okay, the walleyes didn't fare too well, nor did the button bucks, but they aren't people, they were food. The broccoli didn't escape either; I'll wager there's a group somewhere that feels bad for the poor vegies we so brutally chew on.
 
The main carbon cost of hunting is for the gas to get you there and back.
And you also get a reprieve from even that in the fact that you removed a methane machine from daily polluting for upwards of 5 full years or more.
Sort of tax break redneck sort of "Cap & Trade" deal...:D
Brent
 
Since when has any rational, sane comment issued from the UN? I have great difficulty in considering the UN to have any relationship with either reality or common sense.

We're omnivores. Meat contains certain elements we must have. Absent meat in the diet, Big Pharma then becomes our necessary friend--all those supplemental pills and potions.
 
My wife has a friend who doesn't eat meat because she says the texture of it in her mouth makes her gag(I feel sorry for her husband). She does enjoy hunting, though. Her vegetarian status is not because of any moral or religious reasons. She just doesn't like meat.
 
Since when has any rational, sane comment issued from the UN? I have great difficulty in considering the UN to have any relationship with either reality or common sense.

Lots of times. Just not that this time. The UN tries to be a centralized authority on everything so they often end up as an authority on nothing. This is clearly a case of picking the researcher to get an expected outcome. It certainly effects the creditability of their argument. But some will still believe it.
 
Okay, MTT, I exaggerated. :) However, if they were baseball players, their batting average would certainly keep them in the minor leagues. And the ERA is terrible.
 
One of my best friends is a lifelong vegetarian who hunts to feed her family. She enjoys it and doesn't have an ethical conflict -- she simply doesn't like the taste and texture of meat.

pax
 
I personally do not know of any veg's that hunt. I would put that akin to catch and release, but the big problem with hunting is that you cant release. Unless it is a pest ie: varmit, if you shoot it----eat it. Of course thats just the way that I feel about it. Same goes for me with strickly trophy hunting. If you get the trophy and my congratulations by the way, eat it!
 
We're omnivores. Meat contains certain elements we must have. Absent meat in the diet, Big Pharma then becomes our necessary friend--all those supplemental pills and potions.

Well not quite. Any combination of grains and legumes will give a person the proteins that they need. That's why just about every cuisine has some variation on rice and beans.
It is lots easier to get protein from meats, but you don't "need" them.
 
Buzzcook ~

I think when Art said "meat contains certain elements that we must have" which must be obtained artificially if meat is rejected, he was not referring to protein, but to B12 and other related nutrients.

Art, correct me if I'm wrong...

pax
 
One thing that no veggie diet can supply is the healthy fats and cholesterol of good meats. Don't get me wrong, I know pure fat is of little use but them essential fats found in the oils and tissues of meat are not repeated in the vegetable world.
Brent
 
I dont know any vegetarians who hunt but i do know a couple people who deer hunt but just don't really like the taste of venison. I can't see why but it's their choice i guess. For me nothing beats a good backstrap:D
 
I suppose vegetarians could enjoy hunting for things like coyotes, prairie dogs and assorted other varmints that are being a nuisance. Although, some people will eat varmints. Growing up in East Tennessee, it was my job to keep the wood chucks (ground hogs) out of the garden and off of the place. Some old ladies down the road would take the woodchucks and eat them. If push comes to shove, I would eat one. But, if given the choice, I would probably become a vegetarian before eating a woodchuck.
 
Yeah, pax, things like amino acids. Necessary trace elements found only in meat.

So, good health = veggies + grains + fruit + Big Pharma.

One thing about people of the far north: They can survive an entire long winter on nothing but meat, so long as there is fat in the meat. Can't do that on a purely veggie diet, or on freshwater fish. No fat.

Bradford Angier discusses this in some of his writing, as did Farley Mowat in his "Never Cry Wolf". It's also discussed in the writings of various north-country survivalists.

Funny: My big gripe about Army chow was that there was never enough meat. Generally, if I don't get enough meat during some sorta-lengthy period, I get really hard to get along with. When I smell meat cooking, I go to slobbering like an old houn' dawg. :D
 
Back
Top