One of the problems with the older Rems (like the one in the CBS piece) was that the bolt wouldn't open when the safety was "on". That was corrected in the 80's, and modern 700's permit the cycling of the bolt, regardless of the position of the safety. WalterGAII
My understanding is that this is a critical point. The poor woman who shot her boy was supposedly taking her rifle off safe in order to unload it. And, I understand the round went through a horse trailer before striking the boy in the abdomen.
I agree that she should have pointed the gun towards the ground or some other safe direction.
However, I have to admit that I have been interested in this 'problem'. I think we need to be honest with each other.
My boys and I practice the 4 rules. However, there are 'safe' directions for the muzzle, and then there are 'safe' directions. I've seen many, very experienced shooters point the firearm in a 'safe' direction in a gun store. However, while examining the gun, they might point it at the floor, ceiling or a wall. And, if they are examining the firearm at all, then they have to 'paint' some surface, somewhere as they turn the firearm over in their hands.
I've learned about slam fires, and so I am even more alert when chambering a round. However, until a recent, similar discussion regarding the 700, I didn't realize that a firearm was more likely to discharge simply by taking it off 'safe'. Now, that may sound stupid to you old hands, but I don't think it is intuitive to most people.
I've had a fair amount of training now, and I don't recall anyone ever strongly cautioning about this potential problem. Slam fires? Yes. Firing while simply taking the safety off? Nope. Never mentioned in my training.
So, I understand and agree that violating one of the four rules (pointing the muzzle, that is ... from what I hear, some of these are definitely incidents where the finger was
not on the trigger)was necessary for these deaths and injuries to occur. I just feel that this is an unusual situation, and I do think this situation could catch many people by surprise.
Regards from AZ