I just returned from a vacation to the Caribbean. Knowing I'd be in unfamiliar territory (not to mention driving on the "wrong" side of the road!), and reading ahead about some of the crime stats on the island, I elected to stick close to the resort and hire reputable tour agencies to venture out. And I was fine.
I met young honeymooning couple who'd had a terrifying experience. They rented their own car, and ventured out to some remote spot trying to find a hiking trail. Down some windy, isolated side street, a man ran out in front of their slowly driving car and stopped them. He asked where they were going (and they told him), so he ran to the side, opened the back door and climbed in the car with them! Saying he had directions. So, terrified, they followed his directions. Thankfully for them, he actually did bring them to where they wanted to go -- but then demanded money for his service. They just gave him what was in their wallet and he went on his way.
He never threatened them overtly, never showed or suggested a weapon, they didn't argue or resist with their money, so I don't know if it even counts as robbery. But I've been wondering ever since, what I could have/should have done in such a scenario (beyond what I already did, which was not to venture out into unknown territory with bad directions, looking like a lost tourist!)
It's of course a "gun free" island...
Anyways, Scenario 1: I'm in the exact scenario as above, I have no weapon other than my hands or the vehicle. Stranger suddenly runs in front of my moving car and I can't swerve around him on this narrow street. The only thing I can think of is to hit the gas and escape forward when he moves to the side, but I'm already lost and don't know what lies ahead -- could end up stuck, and he's now pissed and knows where I am. But I figure by the time he's in my back seat, I'm now captive and out of options other than to follow direction and pray really hard? He could have a knife, gun, cord around my neck, etc. Trying to attack someone behind me from the front seat sounds futile. Getting out of the car, I could run away -- where? He could have buddies just outside of my vision. He could run off with my car -- an acceptable loss -- but now I'm stranded in a strange place, lost and without any communication. And there were two of them -- if I'm the driver, I also have to consider that my wife is in the car -- if I get out and run, will she? Or have I just left him with a hostage?
What would YOU do?
Scenario 2: this happens in 'Murica, and I have my CCW on me. How might that change the calculus? Still screwed if he makes it into the back seat?
They may have narrowly escaped murder last week -- or he may have just been a real pushy guy who knows how to wring money out of tourists, but the point is, YOU CAN'T KNOW.
I met young honeymooning couple who'd had a terrifying experience. They rented their own car, and ventured out to some remote spot trying to find a hiking trail. Down some windy, isolated side street, a man ran out in front of their slowly driving car and stopped them. He asked where they were going (and they told him), so he ran to the side, opened the back door and climbed in the car with them! Saying he had directions. So, terrified, they followed his directions. Thankfully for them, he actually did bring them to where they wanted to go -- but then demanded money for his service. They just gave him what was in their wallet and he went on his way.
He never threatened them overtly, never showed or suggested a weapon, they didn't argue or resist with their money, so I don't know if it even counts as robbery. But I've been wondering ever since, what I could have/should have done in such a scenario (beyond what I already did, which was not to venture out into unknown territory with bad directions, looking like a lost tourist!)
It's of course a "gun free" island...
Anyways, Scenario 1: I'm in the exact scenario as above, I have no weapon other than my hands or the vehicle. Stranger suddenly runs in front of my moving car and I can't swerve around him on this narrow street. The only thing I can think of is to hit the gas and escape forward when he moves to the side, but I'm already lost and don't know what lies ahead -- could end up stuck, and he's now pissed and knows where I am. But I figure by the time he's in my back seat, I'm now captive and out of options other than to follow direction and pray really hard? He could have a knife, gun, cord around my neck, etc. Trying to attack someone behind me from the front seat sounds futile. Getting out of the car, I could run away -- where? He could have buddies just outside of my vision. He could run off with my car -- an acceptable loss -- but now I'm stranded in a strange place, lost and without any communication. And there were two of them -- if I'm the driver, I also have to consider that my wife is in the car -- if I get out and run, will she? Or have I just left him with a hostage?
What would YOU do?
Scenario 2: this happens in 'Murica, and I have my CCW on me. How might that change the calculus? Still screwed if he makes it into the back seat?
They may have narrowly escaped murder last week -- or he may have just been a real pushy guy who knows how to wring money out of tourists, but the point is, YOU CAN'T KNOW.