best sd ammo for 4in revolver in 357mag

The legendary old standard for the .357 magnum was the Federal Premium 125 grain load. This is a fairly hot, fast, load that's rated well in all the tests in the 1980s. There's nothing fancy about it, it simply works.

I'd advise against extensive use of this load in a SW K-frame revolver. There have been documented issues with flame-cutting in the forcing cone when using this load. Having said that, this is the load I carried in my SW66 when I was patrolling a rural area. I didn't use much of this load for practice shooting, maybe a box a year to rotate stocks and keep my ammo fresh. For practice shooting I used a standard 158 grain load. After 20 years, my Model 66 doesn't show flame-cutting, but I limited the use of this particular ammo.

Still, it's the gold standard for .357 self-defense loads. Good luck finding it in stock.
 
The Remington Express 125 grain SJHP is an old equal to that hot Federal load. It's what I carry in my 4" GP100.

It averages 1451 fps on a 90 degree F day out out of my GP100 for 587 ft/lbs ME.

Hard kicking, and a lot of flash out of the 4" GP100.

You can sometimes find the less expensive UMC 125 grain SJHP at WalMart. Same bullet, but it has a dirtier burning powder than the Remington load, and is in a brass case instead of a nickled, but is loaded as hot.

I used to buy that Federal Classic load at WalMart years ago in boxes of 50 for around $20, but that dried up years ago also.

Now, hottest might not equal best, but I like the Remington Express 125 grain SJHP. I'd use the Federal equivalent if I could find it.
 
125 gr HP's for self defense is what I use. I don't see the value in buying the boutique 357 mag ammo for self defense, but everyone has their own value system.
 
For field use I find the old standby, hard cast 158gr LSW with gas check, with a good charge of 2400, to be the way to go.

For interpersonal use a good 125 to 140 gr. JHP factory load will do fine. Federal, Remington, Winchester, CCI, and others make real good loads.

Find the one that shoots dead on and you can control and that is that.

Rather have 50 fps less velocity and the gun shoots like a dream than something hotter that is not so easy or accurate.

Deaf
 
One of the nice things about the .357 Magnum is that there are very few "bad" JHP loadings. Good choices include (but are not limited to):

Federal 125gr SJHP
Remington 125gr SJHP
Remington 125gr Golden Saber
Winchester 125gr SJHP
Winchester 125gr PDX1
Cor-Bon 125gr JHP
Cor-Bon 125gr DPX
Speer 125gr Gold Dot
Hornady 125gr Critical Defense
Federal 130gr Hydra-Shok
Cor-Bon 140gr JHP
Winchester 145gr Silvertip
Federal 158gr SJHP
Remington 158gr SJHP
Winchester 158gr SJHP

Really, so long as you stay in the 125-158gr range, you've likely got a pretty effective load. The only three common loadings in that weight range that I'd caution against are Federal 158gr Hydra Shok, Speer 158gr Gold Dot, and CCI Blazer 158gr JHP as all three show lackluster expansion in the tests I've seen.
 
You need to come up with a mission profile first.

If its HD, then over-penetration is a serious issue. In that case you would want one of the 38 special HD rounds (maybe even the pink stuff).

357 was intended for highway patrol (or rural) where you could be shooting at care, windshield and various barriers. Its vast overkill for HD in its full tilt loads.

Any of the 38 special HD loads are good for in the house use.

You don't need that high velocity to get reliable expansion out of those rounds these days and you don't want to be going through walls and into neighbors house.

The advantage is it makes a good trail gun and you can then load it up with appropriate rounds for that purpose.
 
In 38spl I use the Federal +P+ 110gr SJHP Treasury Load. It performs flawlessly and does not over penetrate.

Supplement-1.jpg


Negreteslug003.jpg
 
If its HD, then over-penetration is a serious issue. In that case you would want one of the 38 special HD rounds (maybe even the pink stuff).

357 was intended for highway patrol (or rural) where you could be shooting at care, windshield and various barriers. Its vast overkill for HD in its full tilt loads.

Any of the 38 special HD loads are good for in the house use.

You don't need that high velocity to get reliable expansion out of those rounds these days and you don't want to be going through walls and into neighbors house.
Click to expand...

A good hollowpoint in a .357 Magnum is not overly penetrative and, in some cases, the .38 Special penetrates more due to less aggressive expansion. For example, the 125gr SJHP .357 Magnum loadings from makers like Winchester, Remington, and Federal typically penetrate 11-13" in 10% ballistic gelatin while the 158gr LSWCHP .38 Special +P loadings from the same makers can regularly penetrate 15" or more.

As far as penetration of interior walls, just about any centerfire handgun will penetrate several layers of sheetrock quite easily. The best way to mitigate this risk is to develop a home defense plan that positions you to take your shots from angles that represent the lowest risk to bystanders.
 
What's the best sd ammo for a 4 in barrel revolver in 357mag
Click to expand...

Just about any 357mag load is going to be good for self defense. But what I keep mine stoked with is the "FBI load" ; 38spl +P lead semiwadcutter hollow point. It has a long history of being a very effective round w/o all the flash and blast of a full house 357 cartridge.

As always, YMMV.
 
I personally prefer the Speer gold dots in 125 for my 357. They penetrate about 15" or so through 4 layers of denim and then gelatin. The nifty bit is that they also open up to 3/4 of an inch. Hard to beat that even with some 45 loads.
 
.357magnum....

Post #2 said it best. :D

I'd add that for a regular defense round just in the home, you may also want to consider a high quality frangible like Corbons popular Glaser Safety Slug(silver) or the powerful Magsafe .357 load. Some pre fragmented or "exotic" rounds like Extreme Shock USA or RCBD(Le Mas) are not like they claim but there are merits to using a frangible in home defense for Magnum revolvers.

Keep in mind the blast, recoil, muzzle flash, etc. The .357magnum is not for the timid, ;).

ClydeFrog
 
I was considering using Bufflao Bores 125 grain load. Seems pretty hot at arounds 1300 fps. Anyone have thoughts on that load?
 
Expect 1450 fps from a 4 inch barrel for the 125 gr slug.

That is the load that made the .357 the top one shot stopper in handguns.

It is also why the .357 Sig makes just about that.

Kind of loud and some blast but it's a very effective self defense load.

Deaf
 
Have to agree

There are many, many 125 gr loads that are virtually one shot stops. There will be minor variations, but a little research will give you a lot to choose from.
 
One note gang..

The .357 magnum, as loaded with the top 125gr JHPs was mainly used in S&W 27/28, Colt Python, Trooper, and Lawman .357s.

ALL were about 40 oz in weight. And that made them quite controllable.

But the very light weight .357s are not so controllable, especially one handed, with real .357s.

So if you want a 4 inch .357 to use top magnum loads alot I do suggest a Ruger GP-100, S&W L/N Frame revolvers. Yes the light weight guns won't fall apart but they are very hard to shoot for extended practice sessions.

Deaf
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top