I am Uk based, so bow in acknowledgement to all those posters that are speaking from a rather more pragmatic stand point etc.
However, a friend and I used to operate the university rifle and pistol club. Toward the end, we had more female members than male - and it sure wasn't our good looks!
Many of those that came expressed an interest in the defensive aspects of firearms ( see other threads on UK position ). Without becoming elitest, that is the ultimate use of your firearm. Aside from a few 'naturals', far better to start with basic fundamentals, get everything near right and then progress to the defensive weapon.
The .22 gives the student time to grow - much easier to spot potentially fatal errors that can come later.
Read Mas Ayood, Cirillo etc and appears you revert to training under stress. In that vein, whilst remembering that the best defensive weapon is the one you hit the target with, advice seems to steer away from shotguns - unless over penetration is the main issue. At typical defence ranges, shot spread mandates reasonable precise aim - and the shotgun is harder to use than a carbine size rifle. Only you know the precise circumstances - home set up etc. I have not read the thread, but the pay load of a .410 shotgun would seem to risk really annoying an attacker.
I understand that the .223 with soft point/ hollow point loads has a good OSS reputation. Within your existing weapon choice, that would be the way to go. THough, as noted, I am not familiar with the pistol calibre carbines that it appeared you listed.
Finally, my friend and I ended up marrying two of the ladies in question! We have life long ( married 12 and 10 years respectively ) soul mates - and great shooting buddies. Defence with a gun not really an issue in the UK, but both wives could 'cut the mustard' because they are shooting enthusiasts. Some of the other ladies still shoot. Those that came and stayed fixated upon defence gave up shooting and whatever skill set was acquired will by now have greatly diminished.
You are more likely to serve your purpose by encouraging an ongoing general interest in shooting. Also make buying extra kit, guns, goodies much easier!
However, a friend and I used to operate the university rifle and pistol club. Toward the end, we had more female members than male - and it sure wasn't our good looks!
Many of those that came expressed an interest in the defensive aspects of firearms ( see other threads on UK position ). Without becoming elitest, that is the ultimate use of your firearm. Aside from a few 'naturals', far better to start with basic fundamentals, get everything near right and then progress to the defensive weapon.
The .22 gives the student time to grow - much easier to spot potentially fatal errors that can come later.
Read Mas Ayood, Cirillo etc and appears you revert to training under stress. In that vein, whilst remembering that the best defensive weapon is the one you hit the target with, advice seems to steer away from shotguns - unless over penetration is the main issue. At typical defence ranges, shot spread mandates reasonable precise aim - and the shotgun is harder to use than a carbine size rifle. Only you know the precise circumstances - home set up etc. I have not read the thread, but the pay load of a .410 shotgun would seem to risk really annoying an attacker.
I understand that the .223 with soft point/ hollow point loads has a good OSS reputation. Within your existing weapon choice, that would be the way to go. THough, as noted, I am not familiar with the pistol calibre carbines that it appeared you listed.
Finally, my friend and I ended up marrying two of the ladies in question! We have life long ( married 12 and 10 years respectively ) soul mates - and great shooting buddies. Defence with a gun not really an issue in the UK, but both wives could 'cut the mustard' because they are shooting enthusiasts. Some of the other ladies still shoot. Those that came and stayed fixated upon defence gave up shooting and whatever skill set was acquired will by now have greatly diminished.
You are more likely to serve your purpose by encouraging an ongoing general interest in shooting. Also make buying extra kit, guns, goodies much easier!