any other die-hard revolver fans out there?(my recent epiphany)

artech

New member
If so, you'll love this. I just went down to the not-so-local emporium and traded my HK P7M8 for every S&W Mod 15 they had in the place. Here's why.

I got to thinking a while back about handguns in general and how the trends come and go. I have a decent library of older gun mags from the seventies and eighties, and every once in a while like to dig some out and go through them.

This retro reading is actually educational because you can see how the mindset changes through the years. Back then it was a lot more about hitting than capacity, more about tactics than firepower. It got me thinking...

Then a little while ago the wife finally decided to get her carry permit and went to the clases and all. We tried a few different guns and she settled on an old Colt detective special, one of the ones with the exposed ejector rod. It fit her hand and she shoots it well. I figured it was better than a .22, so WTH.

The epiphany started when I shot it. Informally at 50 yards or so, just playing, I could hit damn near anything I shot at. Huh? This while I'm working hard with my Glocks and my HK's and Sigs just to keep groups? I had to figure this out. Another range session with more formal targets proved it. WTF?

Then I started doing some more reading. The best .38 spl loads have about a 80% one shot stop on the street, and the 9mm loads that I used had about the same percentage. The thing was, betewwn the crappy crunch/tick triggers and all the reciprocating mass, I shoot better with revolvers. Single action at distance produces wonderful groups, and in close double action is quick, consistent, and almost foolproof. Jams? Please.

I got another detective special and carried it for a while after shooting it and reinforcing my findings. Jeez, it carries nice, it's light, grip feels good, hey, I can live with this.

I played with the .357 mag for a while a few years back and came to the conclusion that I am a wimp when it comes to recoil. I wore out a 2 1/2 inch mod 66 with full power loads and then swore off magnums. The .38 spl is an ACCURATE bugger, I had all but forgotten that it was THE competition caliber for the longest time.

So, here I am. I've dumped all my semi autos and now have quite a pile of revolvers in varying calibers, frames, and barrel lengths. As I'm writing this, a 2" model 15 is sitting close to hand. I like the feel of the 15 better than the 66 I used to have, the balance seems different. Accurate? Oh yeah.

Yesterday I went to the range and outshot a guy with a 2500 dollar .45 using a 4" mod 15. Yup, I could get used to this. No more autos for me, I'm done with 'em. Caliber? I'm satisfied with it. 158 gr plus P is all I'll ever need. Firepower? I'm not a kid anymore, I'm not blowing off a bunch of rounds just to make noise. Accuracy? Definitely. One shot, one hit. Repeat as necessary.


I never thought I'd be the one saying this, but from here out I guess I'm a wheelgun man. Who would have thought it...


------------------
The M-16 is a damn fine weapon, but your best, your most lethal and effective weapon is between your ears. Ssgt Brown, Parris Island, 3rd Bn, H co. 1984.
 
Yes, I'm a BIG TIME S&W revolver fan. Have been for years, now.

I've got something along the lines of a dozen Smiths.

But, I would NEVER trade my P7M13 for an S&W revolver. Why? Because it's a freaking fantastic gun, too.

------------------
Beware the man with the S&W .357 Mag.
Chances are he knows how to use it.
 
While I personally would not get rid of my autos, I have to agree with your enthusiasm - revolvers simply have character.
 
I just love these topics. I'm something of a greenhorn when it comes to pistols, but I consciously decided to start with revolvers. I love the look of them, the history behind them, the fact that I can dry fire them to my heart's content, and, oh, the reliability. Over time I began to play around a little with semi-auto's and there's nothing more disconcerting for me than getting a stovepipe. As soon as that happens, all of the "what if"s run through my mind and they all converge at this conclusion: the revolver is the gun for me.
It may seem strange to see a person of my tender years pull out his Security-Six at the range instead of a Glock, but I'm comfortable with the fact that I'm a wheel-gun kind of guy.
 
I too love revolvers, Of the 10 handguns I own, eight are revolvers.
Don't get me wrong, I would never trade my Ruger MKII or my Glock 27 for a revolver. The Ruger shoots too well and the Glock has been 100% reliable and conceals too well (although my main carry gun is a S&W airweight .38 wearing a Barami hip grip). However, there is something about a revolver. The classic lines and feel are what does it for me. The beauty(yeah right) of my Glock can not compare. Also, I love the simplicity and ease of operation combined with the strength and reliability.

Good shooting.
 
Count me in, I do love my revolvers. Yes, I do carry an auto pistol daily. A .45 acp Commander. But that don't mean I don't like wheelguns. It just means I also like SA autos. In fact I do own more revolvers than autos. Seriously, when weight and concealability aren't a factor such as camping, hiking or general knockin' around in the outdoors, that'll be a wheelgun on my hip, thank you very much.

------------------
Artificial intelligence is no match for natural stupidity.
 
Artech,

I would not get rid of my semiautomatics (Glocks, Sigs, Colts, Kimbers and H&Ks) -- however, if by some outrageous fortune I were forced retain just one handgun, it would be one of my Smith 627 Special Editions (all stainless, five-inch/fill underlug barrel, gold dot front sight) .357 magnum/.38 Special. Not only is it my most accurate and reliable sidearm, but it is also the most beautiful (IMHO). Moreover, I'm with you regarding personal defense: no "pray and spray" for me; one round, one hit, repeat as required.
 
Welcome to the world of wheelguns Artech. I'm a revolver man from way back. My 2 favorites are my model 13 and my .44 Bulldog. I love um. I too have a model 66. Which I like but am not crazy about. I have a model 36 which is a great lil' belly gun or pocket gun. I have 2 autos. A Springfield SS .45 Super which is my newest acquisition. I also have a Colt Goldcup from the 70's. I don't shoot the auto's as well as I shoot my revolvers. The lastest gun I am looking at is a Gary Reeder Custom .44 with a three inch barrel and a smoothed up action, built on a Ruger .44 Redhawk. He calls it the Alaskan Survivalist. See it at: www.reedercustomguns.com
Thinking about using it as my CCW with .44 specials instead of .44 mags. I'm a big guy so carrying it won't be a problem. Revolvers are my first love. They are also the weapons that I learned on save for a little experience with .45's in the service. I too am a revolver affectionado. Geeze I'm writing a book again. Sorry about the rambling. Welcome back to the world of wheelguns buddy. Enjoy!

------------------
***Torpedo***
It's a good life if you can survive it!
 
Yep, I'm a wheel man . Total wheelman.

I have very small hands/short fingers. So there is simply NO auto-pistol that fits my hand anywhere near as well as my J-Frame with boot grips or my 686 with Hogues.

I have tried several auto-pistols and ended up selling/trading 'em all.
 
WheeeeHeeheeL guns!!!!!!!!!!!!

I admit freely I'm a revolver man. I've owned several of both types-revolvers and semi's. My 'carry' gun at the moment is a Makarov. HOWEVER-I finally found me another .357 with terms and a price that won't wreck my bank account. :)

My opinion-nuthin better than a .357 revolver in one hand and a hardbelly on the other!!!
 
artech,

The .38 spl is still a very common round for revolver competition--sometimes modified a bit though... Things like shortened case for easier reloading, magnum strength loads, etc.

Check at www.ICORE.org for a group representing hard core revolver enthusiasts.

I very much admire my Ruger MKII and would only trade it in for a stainless steel version--I am deadly on blue jobs. However, I have confirmed that I will be lusting only after revolvers as they just feel like they belong in the family. I shoot a S&W N-frame for the most part.
 
Let us not forget the single actions. A slicked up Ruger convertible with .45ACP and .45 Colt cylinders and a pair of Lett custom grips www.lettgrips.com is a lot of fun. www.sixgunner.com

------------------
"He is useless on top of the ground; he ought to be under it, inspiring the cabbages."
Mark Twain
 
Amen. Last night I took the Jeep and went off into the sagebrush to walk, admire the stars, listen to the quiet. Put on my worn Security Six through sheer habit and that was my companion. No thought required.

Gave my son a very nice M15 with Spegel grips some years back. Sure is a nice gun.

BTW, having started in this game in 1959, I agree with the 'fad' thesis. The gun industry (and customers) are as bad as women's fashions. The more things change the more they are the same.

------------------
 
I have had many autos over the years but my SW model 10 is the one on the bed stand. I got it used for 100 bucks. I take it with me on travel trips. If it's stolen I am out 100 bucks.
 
I just recently got back into revolvers after a hiatus with the semi's. Recently, I've been carrying my S&W 60 .357 mag over my 1800 dollar 1911... shhhhhh

------------------
Son
1911 Addiction
"The tree of liberty will grow only when watered by the blood of tyrants."
 
Count me in,

I only own I auto, and it's a 1911. The rest revolvers, Smiths with one Ruger. I got on a serious "I want a SW M14" kick after shooting a friend's box stock M14 at a NRA regional PPC match. I shot this gun better, shooting it for the first time, than I did my custom 1911 that I've put thousands of rounds through. Of course the M14 is discontinued now.

Dave
 
With the exception of hunting revolvers and small airweight 38 smiths I would melt down every revolver out there so more good autos could be made from the scrap metal. Revolvers have a place in history not in todays holsters.
PAT

------------------
I intend to go into harms way.
 
355sigfan,

You are such a trouble maker. LOL
I read the job requirements for Alaska State Troopers on the Net. I know you're not a Trooper, but I'm sure your job shares many of the same characteristics. Stay safe up there.

Dave
 
Back
Top