"Always Rifle" some thoughts

Glamdring

New member
Since Cooper and everyone else has argued over the terms General Purpose and Scout rifle, I figured I would use a different term.

What I am thinking of is a rifle that is light enough and comfortable enought to carry with you 24/7 or as close to that as one can manage.

The primary shooting uses for it (for me) would be plinking, varmints, & if needed Goblins. If I lived in Alaska or Africa I would probably want a bit more gun, because defense against Dangerous Game would be added to the list.

For me I see no point in carrying a rifle that doesn't have much more power or range than a handgun, so it would need to be chambered in a true rifle caliber. But I want it to be comfortable to shoot and carry a lot. To be easy to carry it needs to be light wt, & to remain comfortable to shoot in a light wt gun it needs to have low recoil. So it won't be chambered in a magnum cartridge.

Because of where I live, I can't carry a rifle openly most places. So the rifle needs to be either very compact or takedown so I can carry it cased without it being obvious that I have a rifle with me.

I think the following rifles fit my needs/wants fairly close. Ruger's M77 MII Compact: 5.75 lbs, 16.5" brrl, 36" OAL. Remingtons M7. Savage M99 [takedown version]. And on the larger side the Blaser.

Caliber would be 243 or perhaps 22-250. The Ruger with a Robar modified McMillian folding stock sounds very interesting. With the stock folded OAL should be around 26". If detachable mags are wanted either the Ruger or Rem can be modified to use M1a mags.

Would probably use a 1-4x or 1.5-5x scope. But might use a fixed 2.5x or 4x. I already own a Steyr Scout, but I think my idea of an always rifle would be easier to carry (with folding stock it would be about a foot shorter than my Scout) concealed or low profile. And the 243 has plenty of power for varmints, deer, and goblins as Art likes to point out. But the 243 should be much more fun to plink with in a light rifle than the 308. I think a 90 grain bullet would probably be main bullet, but 70 grain varmint bullets would give less recoil for plinking and varmints.

Would like to hear responses to this idea. Would also like to hear what you would like for an Always rifle. This isn't supposed to be a GP rifle like Cooper's idea. More of a fun to shoot and easy to carry rifle mainly intended for fun shooting, but with enough power, range, & precision to deal with Goblins if need be.
 
I guess my always rifle is an M7 in .308. 2X8 compact B&L scope - set on 2 unless a target presents itself way out there. Good field of view at 2 & quick target acquistion.

I do like the .243 & .22-250 but think they're a bit lightweight for an "always" kinda rifle.

Far as plinkin', downloaded or cast bullets work quite well - minimal recoil.

Folding stocks/PGs don't appeal to me but I don't have any restriction on carrying.
 
Thoughts on an "Always Rifle"

My definition of an "Always Rifle" is one that I always carry. It has to be short and light, reasonably accurate, and tough. It is going to be carried and banged around a lot more than it will be fired.

After trying lever guns and bolt actions I ultimately decided to go with an AR. The shortest one possible fit my needs. The caliber is fine for plinking and varmints and will serve for more serious needs if required.

It has no optics to get dirty or fogged up and no battery powered sighting device to go dead at the least opportune time. For my purposes it is just the ticket. Others will definitely not like this option.

Choices for serious carry guns are like choices of mates. What will prove to be a successful relationship for one individual won't work at all for another.

Just my thoughts, Jack

p.s. Just had another thought: Firearms are like spouses in another way as well. You've got to heat them up on a regular basis to get the most out of the relationship ;)
 
While the notion of having your sweetheart rifle with you all the time is pleasantly romantic, it doesn't seem practical to me unless you live on a farm or a ranch, where you can carry it openly. The odds of you encountering a situation in town where a handgun is needed are remote. The odds against you finding yourself in need of a rifle in town, and yet still having enough time to take a breakdown out of its case and assemble it would seem to be astronomical. I personally think that a rifle in the car trunk and a handgun on your person are a good combination for what Cooper so enjoys calling "goblins."
 
Exactly, Craigz

The only time I am carrying my rifle on my person is here on the ranch. Other times it is hidden in my car or truck. The deal is I always keep it very close. My handgun is always concealed on my person. The only reason I have the handgun is to defend myself on the way to the rifle.
 
I live in Texas and have been told that , yes I could walk around with a rifle slung over my shoulder and if I wasn't pointing it at anyone or doing anything stupid it would be legal...but I should be prepared to explian just why I was doing that.
 
If you can afford it, I would look into a Steyr AUG. That has to be sweetest handling semi-auto I have ever experienced. I could shoot a Coke can off the ground and hit it again before it landed. The AUG is certainly tops when it comes to modularity (is that a word?) and take-down. Assuming this rifle is going to be with you 24/7 for the rest of your life, the thousands investing in obtaining one would be worth it.
 
craigz: Practical? I don't think I used that word at all in this Post :D It is not a question of "need" so much as "want". Is a Sports car or SUV truly practical for most people? Yet, how many people have or want one?

This rifle would spend a lot of time cased riding in my car. It would also get used a lot when I visit friends and family that live outside city limits and enjoy shooting like I do. I don't know about you, but I have noticed with myself that if I load the car up to go shooting with friends I tend to bring too many guns & stuff. Seems like I spend more time loading and unloading the car than shooting :eek:

But if I kept my always rifle around, along with a GI ammo can filled with plinking ammo in the trunk, I would always have one of my own toys along to use or share. And also be less likely to shoot up the ammo for my CCW.

***

The most common targets for this rifle would be plinking targets (ie pop can, clay pigeon, & such), or varmints. Just prefer something more than a 22rf if ever bump into Goblins while carrying it. While I agree that needing a rifle for self defense is a not very likely, if you do have the rifle with you, or within arms reach, almost always if you do ever need a gun then this rifle would probably be available.

This isn't the rifle I would pick for hunting big game or goblins. It isn't a GP rifle, it is a recreational rifle.

***

I considered an AR several times. Main reason I didn't pick it was the power to weight ratio. Most AR's with just iron sights weigh as much or more than my Steyr Scout does with a scope. The Ruger Compact with a light wt stock and compact light wt scope will probably weight about a pound less than my Scout rifle (~6lbs vs ~7lbs).
 
Glamdring:


My 2-cents:

My choice would be my light-n-handy #4 Lee-Enfield/Gibbs "eXtreme carbine" in .303 Brit. (See my post on the "Low profile urban carbine" thread below for details).

Just FYI.
 
I like your term "always" rifle". I also like the term "walk about rifle" as that is what I am looking for in a classic manlicher stocked bolt action. It looks like both Steyr and CZ make suitable .308 Winchester rifles with shorter barrels and full stocks. I haven't actually seen them yet in stores.

At any rate, your idea sounds even more practical than the "Scout" concept.

JJCII
 
my concept would be an AK rifle, reasonably accurate(moreso than most will tell you) always reliable, and if goblin defense is on the list this is the gun to have. it is the perfect compromise between weight and power, basically a semi auto 30-30 with a more ballistically efficiant round( pointy bullets, higher ballistic coeficient). i could blabber all day, but that's my idea. however if you can deal with the slightly anemic caliber, the m-1 carbine is in my opinion the greatest "Always rifle" you can get, it is handier than a lever action, more accurate than a pistol and weighs less than even the compact ruger. If deer are in the mix, head or neck shots will do it, as it is equivelant to a .357 pistol ballistically, and will shoot out to 200 yards. you sound more like a bolt action guy but these are great options.
 
I have one of each---depending on the situation-----Ruger PC4-----Ruger Mini-14 Ranch and a Reminton Model 7 .260 Rem----Any of the three could be considered an always rifle---but its nice to have more than one---lol.
 
M44

How about a Mosin-Nagant M44 Carbine. You can buy one for under 60 bucks, they are accruate and powerful, short, and hold 5 rounds. Take the bayo off and remove the mounting ears and you have a compact powerful carbine that you can hit with out to 300 yds on deer size targets for well under a hundred bucks. If you would lose it, your not out much money. If you've never shot one of these, It might be worth it to you to try one.

I almost forgot to mention, ammo is cheap. I buy 440 round tins for 38 bucks. S&B and many others make hunting ammo too.
 
Remington Model 760 Pump gun in 308 or 30-06, same action as an 870, strong, lightwieght in the carbine model. 10 shot maga available if you want that sort of thing.

Marlin 336 30-30. traditional saddle gun, winchester 94 if you prefer.

Either one makes a fine "truck gun"

Same is true for the venerable Sks. and Mini 30.

The always rifle should be light enough to carry, big enough to kill a deer.

I WOULD say however that the "light rifle" might be a take down 22 like an AR7, or Browning 22 take-down. Evena good old Ruger 10-22 is a viable plinker. As are the 223 class rifles (ar, mini 14 etc)

Since you may show 'need" in your state to have a rifle with you, picking up a license and 'varmint hunting" . its a sport you can do nearly year round in many states.
 
M1 carbine was developed as an "always" rifle for the rear echelon troops...and still didn't supercede the .45 Maybe there's a lesson in that.
 
Oleg.. yes it did. The idea of the carbine was to arm rear echelon troops who would normally only be issued a pistol at best with a lightwieght weapon in face of blitzkrieg moblie war tatics. We quit buying 1911's during ww2, carbines remained in production for years and saw cmbat in WW2, Korea and Vietnam in front line as well as rear echelon units. Carbines were CHEAP compared to machining 1911's.

The pistol hasn't gone away, but would you rather have a 15-30 shot rifle, or a 7-15 shot pistol for medium range shooting??
 
M1 Carbine...But...

;) With a difference!
Anyone in these parts ever hear of the 5.7mm Johnson (AKA the 22/30 & the '22 Spitfire')???
An M1 Carbine rebarreled to 22 cal.and the Carbine case necked down to .22:cool: Loads into the original GI mags, the only modification is the barrel and the ammo, everything else is 'as issued'...Put on a folding Paratrooper stock and it should fit your specs.;)
 
Going back to the original post....

Everything, always there rifle? For food, varmit's, (both kinds), etc?

First off, high cap, large caliber is out for the most part....sorry fellas, no belt fed's this time.

You already know about the Ruger 10/22 for ease of use, detachable magazines for ammo selection, etc... So that's one, but...

You were right on track with the shorty/ultralight .308....and I'll tell ya why...

Ammo selection/availability...not down the road, (though that is a plus), but today. You can buy everything from Hornady's 55 Gr. Sabot's (and light magnums) up to 180 Barnes X Beryllium Copper solid HP's...and everything in between.

We have two .308's of that style...a Remington model 7, and a Ruger MKII M77RLS...both with 18" barrels, and iron sights. I think the RLS was a limited production/discontinued model...a shame really, shorties with sights are the best of all worlds...

Anyhoo, light, robust, and no serious recoil problems...

(Correction: 16.5" barrels...)
 
Last edited:
Glamdring,
By practical, I meant hand-carryable. It sounded as though you intended to be carrying the rifle around with you all the time, which was the reason for wanting a takedown. For a rifle that would sit in the car while in town and be on your shoulder when in the country, the Steyr Scout would seem to be ideal, and it's even made in .243. The biggest problem with that to me would be leaving a $2000+ rifle in my trunk all the time.

The only takedown that I've really lusted after is the Alaskan Copilot .45-70 lever action by Wild West Guns. It fits in a 21" case and weighs 6.5 pounds.

aksafclubcp.jpg
 
My definition of an "always"/scout rifle (same thing, BTW, in my way of thinking) is one that will take down/"do the trick" to anything reasonable, for many/most expected conditions within 300 yards or so (conditions do vary). I look to "moose & down" as a minimum.

YMMV - but "moose" (at 1,000 +/- pounds) does really cover it all.

Yup, .22LR will get small game "better" & cheaper & maybe more quietly. Got one - or several, but ...

An AR (throw yer .30X AK stuff in here) will allow "better" firepower to be delivered "more quickly," Got one - or several, but ....

Regards Glamdrings original post, a .243 - got one, but ....

A .45-70 lever seems like a great choice as would a 12 guage pump (with a variety of loadings), it covers all the bases. Got one - or several), but ....

.30-6/.270, et al - got one (or several) but, ....

Many, many choices.

The most capable caliber/rifle set up that will "do it all" is the .308 in a fairly compact/light-weight bolt action/scoped package.

First = if in a fire-fight - you simply do not want to be there. Period & next.

My M7 (as stated) .308 allows me to kill (with appropriate handloads) anything in the world. With appropriate downloading, I can, with associative POI corrections, do anything else.

What else could anyone want?
 
Back
Top