I'm not trying to open a fresh new debate here but I'd like to address a point you marlin guys have overlooked. First of all, its for his wife who shot the 10/22 & liked it. Now she wants it. With all due respect to this man's betrothed, you won't change her mind now with facts & reason. Unless she is that 1 out of a million for whom logic applies, she'll soon have a 10/22. And that should be just fine because she'll be happy with it since she has already made up her mind about it. Make her get the marlin when she wants the ruger & she'll hate the marlin. This post is in no way meant to be derogatory to women. I'm just high-lighting some fundamental differences & doing my best to mask my underlying bitterness earned from years of being married to a woman who operates solely on emotion. Logic is out there. So is Pluto. Neither have any effect on the day to day.