Now the argument becomes about shootability, etc. 2.5"X.357=LOUD! I prefer the .38 for its milder characteristics. However, there is no doubt that the .357 has more energy. The question is, is it worth it out of a snub pocket gun?
I have two "lightweight" .357's - a 13 ounce S&W 360 and a 17 ounce Ruger LCR. I bought both intending to shoot .38s or Cowboy .357's. I like the 158 grain Cowboy RNFPs. I also like the Grizzly 158 grain hard cast WFN .38s either standard pressure or +P. Stronger lightweight gun made sense for me. The "wife" from the above post who shoots .357s out of a short barrel gun must be using a SP101. If she can shoot a 13 ounce gun with .357s she must be quite a "woman."
I prefer the .38 for its milder characteristics. However, there is no doubt that the .357 has more energy. The question is, is it worth it out of a snub pocket gun?
That is the real question and one that each person must answer. For me the answer is a resounding YES, however, I preface it with a steel gun. The ScTi 357 J frame is the most miserable gun I have ever fired and was still worth it to me in moderation, except the gun would not take it.
