bamaranger
New member
not really
The issue is things are not really equal. What I mean is that to gain the advantage that each caliber you mention offers, one has to go to the extremes.
I believe that the .270/130 combo, in a full size bolt rifle around 8 pounds, kicks a bit less than any full size .30 with 150's or more. That is not an apples v. apples study, but if you want a lighter kicking rifle, you shoot the .270/130. Old man Newton at work.
Conversely, if you want a deeper penetrating performer, say you were going to wander about big bear country with your .30, you might load 200-220's and that will get your attention quick in a sporter weight bolt rifle. My 20" mannlicher Mauser Mark X '06 shoots 200's like a house afire, spooky....but I pay a price, as its the most vicious kicker I own.
But to simplify, the .270-.308-'06 are not that far apart and if you can shoot one, you can shoot the others.
The issue is things are not really equal. What I mean is that to gain the advantage that each caliber you mention offers, one has to go to the extremes.
I believe that the .270/130 combo, in a full size bolt rifle around 8 pounds, kicks a bit less than any full size .30 with 150's or more. That is not an apples v. apples study, but if you want a lighter kicking rifle, you shoot the .270/130. Old man Newton at work.
Conversely, if you want a deeper penetrating performer, say you were going to wander about big bear country with your .30, you might load 200-220's and that will get your attention quick in a sporter weight bolt rifle. My 20" mannlicher Mauser Mark X '06 shoots 200's like a house afire, spooky....but I pay a price, as its the most vicious kicker I own.
But to simplify, the .270-.308-'06 are not that far apart and if you can shoot one, you can shoot the others.