$1,200 - what would you buy or build?

sir_n0thing

New member
I'm currently siphoning off a little money every week into a gun-fund. The goal is to buy a new rifle this year, late summer or early fall. The plan is to have around $1,200 available for the rifle alone, before optics.


The purpose of this rifle will be more of a thing of beauty rather than a purely functional tool, thus I want a nice wood stock and heavier weight rather than a synthetic ultra-light rifle. I already have a synthetic light weight gun, that's not what I'm after right now.

This rifle will go out on range days for sure, and possibly deer hunting from a stand as well. It won't be a safe-queen, but will be handled with care as I am no where near flush enough to afford a bunch of rifles. I have to be selective and careful with what I buy.


My criteria as of right now will be:
•Price for rifle without scope somewhere between $1,000 and $1,300
•Bolt action
•Nice wood stock (highest grade I can get in that price range)
•Longer barrel (24" - 26")
•Not a "light weight" rifle. In the neighborhood of 8 pounds is a good starting point.


As far as caliber, I'm considering several. .243, .260, .270WIN, .270WSM, 7mm-08, 7mm mag, .300WSM are on my short list. To be honest I am leaning toward .270WIN, .270WSM and maybe 7mm-mag. Comments about those calibers are welcome, but the caliber is secondary to the rifle itself, so no need to turn this into a ".308 vs .30-06" type of discussion! ;)

To give an example of what I've looked at so far... Winchester 70 Supergrade, TC Icon, Browning X-Bolt, Weatherby and Sako, etc. all some make beautiful guns.

I have also considered buying a barrel and action or a barreled action, stock, etc and building ground-up.

So, all that said, what would you buy (or build) and why? Comment on wood quality, build quality, actions, triggers, barrels, etc.

I'm really looking forward to hearing everyone's response on this one! I'm betting that given $1200 to spend there will be a lot of different results from everyone here. :)
 
Personally I would go with an Icon precision Hunter with a good quality scope in 243, although I'm bias as I have a new Precision Hunter in .204 ruger 11lbs with scope shoots .375 with commerical ammo and I am testing loads that that shoot .250 or under, wood, fit and finish are excellent on this gun.


Down side I read T/C sold out to Smith and Wesson so don't know how long the quality will remain.
 
Either a Browning X-Bolt Medallion or a Winchester M70 Featherweight Deluxe. I wouldn't limit myself to 24" barrels.

Or save a few hundred more and get a Cooper.
 
+1 on the Winchester, but if you have the skills a project gun could be a great experience and you will end up with a true custom that you will be proud of. I'm looking for just the right Mauser action to do the same thing. I'd love to make a custom fit and finished stock.
 
given your financial criteria i'd go with a Winchester M70 Supergrade, although, i'm pretty sure their prices have gone up since last year and are a little more than $1200. if I had more money i'd get myself a nice Weatherby Mark V....those have some beautiful wood stocks
 
There are a couple of nice Brownings in 270 and 30-06 over on Auction Arms today. I was doing a caual browse, drool search earlier.
 
For that kind of $$$

I would contact wyosmith (found on this forum) and let him custom build what I wanted..........

As to calibers for all around use 30-06 is still number 1:D

But for me personally, I don't want beautiful wood because I find them too pretty to beat around in the brush and they wind up being safe queens......
 
Cowboy Mo is right about worrying about beating up a beautiful rifle, but if you really want a beautiful rifle, the prettiest thing I've seen in a long time was made by Cooper Rifles. Every thing about it was lovely, and it had a great accuracy guarantee. Made me weak in the knees. Like looking at a new Ferrari or the front cover of the SI swimsuit issue. I don't know what the entry level price is though (on the rifle...). If I thought I could get one (the rifle) without the wife finding out......
 
Given your specs and money, I'd build a Remington 700 with the stock of your choice and a light varmint contour, 20" barrel in either .260 Rem or 7mm-08.

Magnums do nothing for me anymore, and I believe that either of the above would do what you want very nicely. I don't do wood stocks either as they are always to pretty to take out in my opinion, and I don't like having to baby any of my guns. (That's why they all sport plastic and Krylon!)
 
I just looked at Cooper's website. The reference to Ferrari and SI covers is not far off at all! Wow, some beautiful rifles...

EDIT: $3195 :eek:
 
I was going to say i'd sale you my sako 85 hunter for a grand but it's .260 rem and 22" barrel. Beautiful wood, smoothest action i've laid hands on, right around 7-8lbs. Other than that i would opt for the super grade Winchester. Cooper and (Pre remington) Dakota are the standards IMO of super nice grade rifles. They cost a fortune, but if your looking for a nice rifle and 1/2 MOA guarantee. Dakota's i would take to a step further, i held my uncles and i just couldn't understand how someone would take it out of a glass case lol. It's literally something to be admired rather than to be used.

But for me personally, I don't want beautiful wood because I find them too pretty to beat around in the brush and they wind up being safe queens......

+1 ^. Exactly why i'm selling my Sako 85. I just can't bare to scratch it, hunt with it, or anything other than bench shoot. It's just too nice of a rifle. My father wants me to give it to him... but his way of thinking "scratches provide memories of hunts"
 
Last edited:
E.R. Shaw - Check it out!

Before you make a decision check out E.R. Shaw, the barrel makers, who also offer rifles configured to customer specifications from an a-la-carte selection yielding over 75,000 combinations. I think almost all of those combinations will fall within your budget. It's called the Mk VII Rifle. I have spent over 6 hours with their online gun builder and I still haven't made a decision :o

I do wish they would offer a larger selection of stocks...

I only found out about this last week (shame on me since I live in the same city) and I called and spoke to them and am going to stop in and see them at the NRA National here in Pittsburgh next month. They get excellent reviews all over the internet. Really nice choices!

The only downside is that there is over a year turn-around. They must be doing something right...

-ershawbarrels.com-

back to reloading...
 
^^^^ER SHAW^^^^

Every barrel I've slapped on a rifle has been an ER Shaw. I have absolutely no complaints with their barrels. I don't know about the rifle, but I suspect it will be quite nice and very accurate.




I still think building your own would be way more fun
 
Back
Top