Most reliable .357 lever

I only have personal experience with the Marlin 1894, mine runs .38 Specials like oil on glass, PROVIDED you aren't using SWC or WC bullets.
 
I have heard good reports from people using the Henry steel 357. My first hand experience with a single example of Rossi's 357 carbine, insures I will not buy another one.
 
Marlin

Pre-safety Marlin runs .38's, (except WC) just fine. Single loaded WC is about like shooting a .22............very mild. Shot quite a bit of .38/110gr JHP from mine w/ no issues.
 
I haven’t shot a lot of .38sp in my Henry BBS, but I’ve shot enough in RN,RNFP, TCBB, and SWC to know it feeds all these just fine. Both 158gr and 125gr. But since I have a ton of .357 brass I pretty much shoot them with all types of bullets with equal reliability.
 
Sarge said:
I have heard good reports from people using the Henry steel 357. My first hand experience with a single example of Rossi's 357 carbine, insures I will not buy another one.
Click to expand...
And yet my Rossi 92 cycles 38 special and 357 just fine. The trigger is good and it is accurate. The issue with many of these guns is not that they are all crap, it's inconsistency gun to gun.
 
armednfree said:
And yet my Rossi 92 cycles 38 special and 357 just fine. The trigger is good and it is accurate. The issue with many of these guns is not that they are all crap, it's inconsistency gun to gun.
Click to expand...
I never said they were 'all crap'. Your words, not mine.

I've had three Rossi 92s, two 45 Colts and a 357. The 45s were good to great and the 357 was a PITA. QC with them seems to be Luck of the Draw. I was shopping for a 44 Mag recently and asked the guys at Rossi Rifleman for their experience on recent production Rossi 44s. The results are not encouraging.
 
Last edited:
One guy here had a serviceable Rossi. It would feed Specials but it was ugly with a tropical mung wood stock and indifferent blue.

Another Rossi owner had his fixed up. The "action job" included polishing the cartridge guides nice and shiny... and rounded off to where they would not handle Specials, he had to use light load Magnums for CAS.
 
I’ve got a Rossi .44, 16 inch barrel. It feeds magnum is specials, factory or hand loads. No problem. Perhaps I just got a good one.
 
Are presently produced Marlins as good as the "older" ones?
Click to expand...

As far as I know, there are no presently produced Marlins. After Remington took them over (and moved the factory) the rifles they made (called by some "Remlins) were of substandard quality for several years, according to the Internet, I can't say from personal experience, I never had one... Again, according to what people were saying, the Remington Marlins had begun improving and were decent guns the last few years they were made.

Remington is no more, they were destroyed by corporate greed and have been sold off in bits.

I understand that Ruger bought the Marlin part, and will be making them "the way they should be" but hasn't started, yet.

I (foolishly) traded off my 1895 some years back, and am now down to just 2, a 336 .30-30 and an 1894 .357 Mag, both pre-safety guns, and good ones.

The old pistol caliber carbines bring a premium price these days, but I would pay that before getting one of the Remington made ones. Hopefully Ruger will do justice to their version when it gets here. No way to know till then.
 
.38 Special is the most popular cartridge in cowboy action shooting. The top rifle in the sport is the Uberti 1873 which comes in .357. Feed it .38 Special ammo with a COAL of at least 1.45” topped with a TCFP or RNFP bullet and you are “off to the races”.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top