XS Big Dot's..

My assessment coupled with yours, XS Big Dot sights?

  • Yay

    Votes: 18 56.3%

  • Nay

    Votes: 14 43.8%
  • Total voters
    32
  • Poll closed .
T

Tactical Jackalope

New member
What do you guys think about XS Big Dots?

XS Big Dot

I'm curious to know peoples assessment of these sights. I can't really fully commit to something that I don't know. I don't have the patience to be changing night sights at random. I am very curious about these.

I feel like they are easy to acquire on a quick draw. But in my experiences you don't necessarily use your sights if you're doing a quick draw to engage and fire. It's draw, point, and shoot.


Here's where I am held back from buying them.

I feel like with something like Trijicon HD's (which I have) you have the best of both worlds. Precision of the notch / 3-dot sights. With the front sight being nice and bright.

With XS (or so it appears to me) you only have close quarter precision. Along with a faster sight picture in transitioning between targets.

I'm considering them for a CCW. Specifically my Glock 19. I'm getting a new Slide and barrel from Glock. So might as well search for new sights.

So what's your take on XS's big dots? Use them? Used them? Love them? Hate them?
 
Last edited:
Have a XS Standard Dot Tritium Express Set on my Sig P226. Very fast. I like them a lot. I prefer them over three dot tritium sights.
 
When I first started shooting handguns, I tried a set of XS Big Dots on my Mother In Law's Glock 26. At first, I really hated them, because, especially at longer ranges, they weren't particularly accurate. With a G26 and standard sights, I got tighter groups at greater than 15 yards. Once I started learning more, and realizing that an inch or two at 25 yards isn't a huge deal, I realized how much I liked them. I don't have a set currently, but am seriously looking at getting some soon. They are so fast. You mention how you might not use the sights if it's a quick draw type situation, but unless you're shooting from some kind of compressed or retention position, your sights will be in front of you, and that big dot is so easy to pick up.

See if you can find a gun with them you can shoot. I wish I had gotten them when I was looking at replacing my sights originally. As soon as I can justify it, I'll probably look at getting a set. They're just so fast and quick to pick up.
 
I've never been a huge fan of the "dotting the i" style of sights. I find I can transition from Target to Target faster with a three dot setup simply because its what I'm used to. If it were me and money wasn't an issue, I would probably go ahead and get a set for the new slide but I wouldn't carry it. Otherwise I would just put the money towards something else.
 
I like and use XS sights on a couple of my pistols.

The XS sites are accurate and are not given enough credit for the level of precision they are capable of yielding. In my opinion within 20 yards they cannot be touched (especially for defensive purposes.) My previous sentence does not mean they are inaccurate past 20 yards. For longer rage shooting you will need to practice with them. I shoot out to 50 yards with no problem, but I am not shooting at golf balls I shoot at 14” steel plates.

I attached a picture of the XS Big dot sight next to a stock Glock front sight. The “big dot” is only slightly larger in size. I hope this post helped a little.
 

Attachments

  • BIG Dot.jpg
    BIG Dot.jpg
    239.1 KB · Views: 244
I sincerely expected to have more negative feedback from this forum on these sights. Thanks for the honesty.

Been wanting them. I guess I'll get them and try them out. If I don't like them on my CCW G19 I'll put them on my Glock 17.

I've read that some have issues past XX yards. Others don't.. etc etc. I'd rather draw my own conclusion then I guess. Too many mixed feelings on them.
 
When I bought my PM9 (used) it had the XS Big Dot on it. I was not at all impressed. It's been five or six years, so I don't recall, but I either shot very high or very low with them.

For me it was very unlike anything else I owned and I did not see any advantage. I was unwilling to make that adjustment (or convert everything else over to match). I swapped out for traditional three-dot night sights. My PM9 is a keeper. The Big Dot...not so much.

If you only have one gun, and it has this sight, that may work well for you.
 
I either shot very high or very low with them.
Click to expand...


I think I've heard that the most.

See? That's the other side of my brain. Telling me to stick to what I already know.

I don't know anyone here that has XS big dots on their gun. Wish I could try them out.

Cause I'm really thinking about trying them out on my own dime. But it'll be a waste if I end up not liking them.
 
Decided I'm not going to get them.

While I carry my Glock 19 and know I can "get used to" these sights. I don't only CCW, I'm an avid shooter as well and a collector. So I'm going to pass on changing the sights on my main handled and fired gun that I depend my life to.

Just going to get HD's or something.
 
Meh

I have XS sights on a Glock 23.
With lots of effort and care, and slowing down to fine-tune my sight alignment, I can be accurate with them. Otherwise I have the shooting too high or too low problem with that big fat dot.
I prefer regular 3-dot night sights though and have them on everything else. Just as accurate, and for me at least as fast to use regular 3-dot sights as the XS sights.

I don't hate my XS sights and have no plans to replace them, but I'm not planning to buy any more either. Regular 3-dot for me going forward.
 
They look great on the Bobcat/Tomcat in the picture on their sight. I say for smaller guns they are a must. Who was the 3 that said "nay" are they pirates? :eek:
 
I had a set on my CZ PCR. I replaced them.

I'm faster and far more precise with standard sights.

While the sights were amazingly fast at close ranges, I realized I could be almost as accurate, and even faster not using sights at those ranges.


That said I fully intend to get a big dot front on my J-frame. I've held a snubby that had one, and it just worked somehow.
 
I like the "dotting the I" sight picture but prefer the XS standard dot front sight over the XS big dot front sight.
 
ahequ4yb.jpg


Now I'm just waiting for my Glock 19 to get back.
 
I have the "Big Dot" sights on both of my SIG-Sauer every day carry pistols.

After trying out half a dozen different night sights, I settled on the Big Dots.

Thus far, I have seen no down side to them.:)
 
I have an XS Big Dot night sight on one of my Hi-Powers, oddly, it isn't the big dot I have a problem with but the rounded top. I am used to seeing the corners in crisp focus to verify I am focused on the front sight and just could never get used to the rounded top of the XS.

Also, for myself personally, I am not seeing any speed advantage over my Novak sights when I break out the timer. The flip side of that is I am not seeing the often reported downside to long range accuracy either. In fact, one of my best shots ever - a 50yd knock down of a popper from the running board of a Ford Explorer was made using a XS Big Dot.
 
I like mine

Then again the big dot is on a shotgun In my case. Constantine if you don't like em maybe I will buy em off you.
 
I went from a set of XS Big Dot sights to a normal front night sight and a dotless Novak RR. My group sizes went from ~3.5" to ~1" at 15 yards. I feel like I have lost zero speed.

IMO, they are a system which seems like they would be the best, but they are about the same. Accuracy is awful. My eyes never seemed to care if it was centered in the V and the bias of the V on bottom always made me shoot low.

To add to this, I would avoid TRO's also. They are too big for their mounting foot size...read can be moved by a moderate impact.
 
I would love to have an aimpoint on my EDCpistol if it was available in a package the diamter of a cigarette and 1/2 inch long.:)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top