Would you trade...

[BamaMac54]

A 2.5" Smith 686 Stainless 357 mag for a 4" Colt King Cobra in 357 in exactly the same shape? I'm curious on what to do. I like the Smith but have a soft spot in my heart for Colts

 

[Ala Dan]

Greetings BamaMac54-

Well, it just depends on what you are going to use a .357 magnum for~?
In my way of thinking, the 2.5" barrel S&W model 686 would be a bit too
heavy for an all day CCW; but on the flip side of the coin is the fact that
the Colt King Cobra has a longer barrel, and thus harder to conceal. I just
acquired a S&W model 66-4 (SMIF K-frame) .357 magnum; for those
times when I might want to CCW that caliber, which is rare these days
as I much prefer the .45 auto. So, I would say get the Colt and enjoy
punching some paper.

 

[BamaMac54]

This wouldn't be for carry..simply for the satisfaction of having a good 357 mag...

 

[model 25]

If you can get a chance to shoot both then compare the accuracy and keep the one that shoots straightest for you. If you can't then your guess will be as good as mine.

25

 

[Majic]

Either one is a good .357 revolver, but since you say you have a soft spot for Colts (which I fully understand) then make the trade. You won't go wrong either way.

 

[shooter1]

Of the two, I'd prefer to own the Colt. For carry, the shorter barrel and stainless finish make it a better choice. Any way you can own both?
str1

 

[Longbowshooter]

Yes.

 

[BamaMac54]

Well, I'm happy to say I'm the proud owner of a Colt King Cobra...fun stuff

 

[SJshooter]

Trade it for a Python or keep it. But pass on the Cobra.

 

[BamaMac54]

Here's a pic of my new family member

 

[jonnyringo]

No, I would keep the Smith.