I use a full size EAA Witness in .38 Super; my wife uses the polymer compact. It's a matter of hand size. Both guns are accurate and readily consume a wide variety of hand loads (fast/slow, heavy/lite, cast/jacketed) without indigestion. Less fussy for us than the 9mm's. We're not competative shooters, i.e. we don't usually load up to IPSC major, but it looks like we've gone through a few boxes of primers, 10k's here, 10k's there (count confused by a few other cartidges). I remember drifting the rear site on the full size when I first got it, no other work or problems.