The Classics are nice guns. They had good grade wood also (the other one I've seen recently had much fancier wood than the picture shows). Try to buy that grade wood, even as a blank, and it would probably cost more than the gun.
The commemoratives dont get much respect, but they generally have better finish, often better wood, and are made with octagon barrels, which are otherwise unavailable unless in a much older and more expensive gun. Most of the octagon barrels shoot better than the average carbine. I've had a number of both commemoratives and pre-64 carbines, I'd prefer several versions of commemoratives to the average late pre-64 carbine as far as a shooter goes. Swapping out the carriers for a forged one is simple, and didnt cost much when I last did it. Don't know what they cost now.