Don't know it this will help but here goes.
When I got my police/HD short barrel for an 870,I picked one threaded for chokes so loads could be tuned with Imp/Mod Cyl. chokes. Along the way a rifled extension turned up and it gave me the chance to try saboted slugs.
Turns out the combo rocks out past 100 yards and solves not only my desire for a slug gun but also a light urban rifle with a nasty punch.
Now for your problem; A nieghbor got the barrel crushed on his elderly off brand family pump gun and could'nt find one anywhere and he really loves that gun. My deal with my pump gave me the idea and we took it to a local smith and he made it work.
Basically just cut the barrel off and threaded it for the rifled extension,then cut another barrel from his scrap can and cut a piece to replace missing part of his barrel. He was careful about the contour and the machining of the shoulder and threads on the extension and with a crush washer and some small cuts for a spanner to tighten the barrel on and off,BINGO!
My nieghbor now has his gun back,a slug gun and an HD and long barrel with chokes for both.Man is he jazzed.
The smith was pumped because he'd never considered that fix on a damaged barrel before and now everbody is happy.
Don't know if your Ithica is threaded for chokes or if you feel it's worth this much trouble but if it's an heirloom gun or something it might be a soulution and it should'nt hurt the original configuration of the gun.Plus it could give you other options you had'nt considered.(don't quit when you're hit)