The poll needs a "none of the above" option.
I was an Army Small Arms repairman in the 70s when the Army used the Win 1200, and the Marines used the Rem 870. Only time in my life I ever thought the Marines got the better deal. I have zero interest in anything Winchester has since developed from that action.
Never took to the Mossbergs. Nothing wrong with them, I just never liked them much.
I'm a geezer, and have no interest in anything with the word "Tactical" as part of the name. #1, its poor grammer, and #2, normally means the gun has some feature(s) that I don't have a use for. If you do, by all means, enjoy!
I also make a distinction between home defense and combat. My idea of defense is more "repel boarders", than "clearing the house".
The "on duty" shotgun in my house is actually a cheap Chinese made 12ga rabbit eared coach gun. The main reason is because it is simple enough even my not mechanically inclined wife won't screw it up. OK, its only a double barrel, but so what? Two shots that I know she can put in her bedroom door at need give me more confidence than a 5,6,7 etc shot pump where she can short shuck the action, forget the safety, etc. If she (or I) were 100lbs lighter and 40 years younger, I'd pick something else!