Which one:Sig 228/226, or H&K 9mm C?

G

geegee

New member
I own a H&K .40C, which I really like...a lot. I'm thinking of picking up a 9mm, but can't decide which one. I have owned a Sig Sauer 228 and found it's accuracy to be outstanding (please don't ask why I got rid of it-I don't wan't to feel perplexed and stupid) . I've never owned a 226, but like the balance and feel in my hand. If I buy the H&K Compact, I'll have the advantage of already owning several holsters (for my .40C) that will fit it perfectly.

Decisions, decisions. Which one would be your preference and why? :confused: geegee
 
Plus, you have the added advantage of all your 40 mags ;) I've been using my USPc 9 w/ USPc 40 mags. So far, I'm happy to report 1000+ rounds w/ no failures of any kind :D
My recommendation, get the HK. You already know the manual of arms and you already have accessories that will cross over.

Or, there is option #3...Get both! ;)
 
All are outstanding firearms, but if I had to narrow the field
down; I would choose the Sig-Sauer P228, or in military terms
the M11. Perfect balance, and as you have already mentioned;
great accuracy. Why else did I pick the P228? I prefer the feel
of the aluminum frame, over that of polymer. Why not the P226?
I don't care for the P226's "European" grip angle; as opposed
to that of the P228. When all is said and done, any of these
choices will make for an excellent firearm. Stay safe, shoot
straight, and have fun-

Best Wishes,
Ala Dan, N.R.A. Life Member
 
I really hate DA first shots, so I would... and did... go with the USP9c, but the 226 is an exellent gun.

I have 25,000 rounds through mine with one, very recent, failure. The c-clip on the guide rod broke off. I didn't notice this until I cleaned it because the gun continued to function flawlessly even with the clip missing. I called H&K on a Thursday afternoon and received a new, redesigned guide rod, spring and washer (no c-clip thanks to the redesign) on the following Tuesday.
 
I have had my Sig 228 for years now. Shoot it all the time and have NEVER had a single mis-feed or any other problem what-so-ever. I think it is the perfect combination of a nice out of the box trigger, concealable size, good accuracy, plenty of capacity (13 rounds) and of course price. I have had many other guns but Sig is still my favorite.
 
Both good guns. Both accurate and reliable. I give the HK the edge in durability, lighter weight and more compact dimensions. In addition you are already familiar with its MOA which is a lot different than the Sig.
 
My initial thoughts in response:
1.Use the same mags ? Man, that's huge, as I own more than a couple of 40 cal mags.
2.Familiarity with MOA for the H&K...can't be discounted...great point.
3.Sig's reliability, accuracy, and dependability. I put all of these (in my experience) equal to my H&K.
4. Something I've noticed:there are some pretty good deals on GunsAmerica for used Sigs, with LE mags. Probably break even.
5. WTF? :confused:
Predictable outcome: Guess I'll probably wait until a huge moment of weakness strikes me at a Gun Show, and buy the first one of the three I see. Yeah, that's a plan :eek: . geegee
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top