Which is better for CQB, M4 or MP5 ??

Status
Not open for further replies.

Snapsho7

New member
I was wondering what everyone thought the best weapon was for CQB (Close Quarters Battle). I mentioned the M4 and the HK MP5 above but feel free to mention whatever firearm you think is the best suited.

My favorites are the M4 and the MP5 for several reasons. Both are very flexible (optics, lights, special purpose launchers, etc).

There are also several major differences between these 2 systems, caliber and size being the main ones.

So tell us which weapon you think is best suited to engage targets from 0 to 100 yards in an urban or street to street situation.
 
I'd think the MP-5 would be best suited for urban CQB for several reasons. It's got the versatility and response desired at close range battles. It's about 5lbs (depending one variation) but packs a mean 9mm rapid fire. F.B.I. uses the MP-5 chambered in 10mm, which is almost the equivalent as shooting the assailant with the Nascar 500 :).
I like the FN-P90. It's shorter than an MP-5 A1 and M4. It fires the 5.7X28mm round and holds about 50 bullets. Too bad only the Brits use it :\.

"I refuse to be outgunned by criminals!"
 
http://www.unsuave.com/~hkpro/pdw.htm

<BLOCKQUOTE><font size="1" face="Verdana, Arial">quote:</font><HR>What appears upon first look to be a weapon design to compete with the FN series P90 in 5.7mm x 28, the PDW promises to be a huge
improvement on that system. Though no one could fault the engineers at Fabrique Nationale for their vision, the P90 has one reported serious
flaw. If you drop a partially loaded magazine, or the gun with a partially loaded magazine, rounds will go flying, get disoriented in the magazine
and seriously jam the mechanism.

The 4.6 x 30 is also reported to be ballistically superior to the 5.7 x 28, especially at longer ranges. It has a reported muzzle velocity of 725 m/sec.
(Roughly 2200 FPS)

The heavy use of polymer again shows the design direction that the HK engineers are taking. With a conventional 20 round magazine in the
pistol grip or an optional 40 round magazine that extends below the gun, one of the most amazing aspects of the gun is its size, or lack thereof. It
is roughly the size of a SOCOM pistol!

Sporting a retractable shoulder stock and a very small heads up display sight reminiscent of the Eotech/Bushnell Holosight, the PDW also has a
T-shaped cocking handle somewhat like the M16 series.

Select fire, with safe, semi and full auto modes of fire, and production models sporting the now familiar red and white bullet in box pictograms,
the stated cyclic rate on full automatic is 950 rpm. The PDW has a foldable forward vertical grip. The magazine is conventional staggered box,
and the magazine release behind the trigger guard looks almost interchangeable with the USP series handguns.

Several features of the G36 series are present in the PDW as you can see in the photos below. Extensive use of polymer, the rotating bolt and
gas system all reflect the G36 series.

The PDW is a quintessential reminder of the lead that HK continues to take in small arms design.[/quote]


[This message has been edited by dZ (edited April 05, 2000).]
 
Moved to the AF/CQC forum.

------------------
"I know that you believe you understand what you think I said, but I am not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant." -Nixon
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top