The three biggest problems with "painted" finishes, are:
1...The do-it-yourselfers. No, I have nothing against them. After all, I started out the same way 30 plus years ago. The problem is that many of them believe the advertising. "Just degrease and spray it on", "no preparation required", "it's impervious to everything, including bullets", etc. Then when the finish falls off, flakes off, rubs off, melts off from some cleaning solution, etc. it's the finishes fault. Now factor in the "professional" do-it-yourselfers! Those are the ones who "do it for a living". They get an FFL so they can order firearms and then go into the gun refinishing business to make spending money. These guys are hacks! Here's some photo's of one of those jobs. Warning! They're disgusting!
http://www.shootiniron.com/PHOTOS.html#*. (Scroll to the bottom of the page)
2...The expectation that any finish is a do-all finish. This finish looks wonderfull, that finish will not reflect light, the other finish will never rust, their finish will never come off, etc. Some finishes are good for this and other's are good for that. None will do everything. What do YOU want from a firearms finish? Cost, durabilty, rust resistant, tactical, etc. all play a part in that decsion.
3...The outright lies and other misleading advertisng! One manufactrurer claims that their finish is Mil-Spec. Ok, what's the Mil-Spec? It's for that finish as used on dump trucks, not firearms! Another claims that their finish requires only degreasing. Yeah, right! Then there's the claim that it's resistant to all known chemicals. Ask them what chemicals and for how long? Some of them will purchase anothers finish in bulk and re-package it as their own.
The bottom line is that some finishes are better for many things on many different firearms but none are perfect for everybody on all firearms. Keep yer powder dry, Mac.
Tuff-Gun Finishes. The Name Says It All.
Mac's Shootin' Irons, LLC.
http:
www.shootiniron.com
Tucson, Arizona.