What is Carbon Steel?

DarkMatter

Inactive
I'm looking to buy a S&W 442, 642, or 642LS.

M442 is Aluminum Alloy/Carbon Steel and M642/642LS is Aluminum Alloy/Stainless Steel. What's the difference? Which one is better for pocket carry? Which one will last longer?

Thanks for any info!
 
Carbon steel is "regular," non-stainless steel. The amount of carbon in the steel, along with other impurities in varying degrees, determines the properties such as hardness, brittleness, and elasticity.

Before stainless there was only "steel," today called "carbon steel" to distinguish it from stainless steel.

Sorry if the explanation is rather circular...
 
Technically, carbon steel is steel which contains more than .5% carbon. Generally, the carbon steels will be a tad tougher than their stainless counterparts, but that applies more to knives and tools than guns. The carbon steel will also rust quite easily, as opposed to the stainless, which will be much more resistant. That might be important if you want to carry this gun, or live around an ocean.. :)

A good page on steels, though in knife terms
 
Most modern blued steel firearms are manufactured from "medium" carbon steel, usually 4340, often called chromoly steel. Additives (aproximate)in 4340 are Carbon .40, Manganese .70, Phosphorus .035max, Sulphur .04 max, Silicon .15-.35, Chromium .80, Nickel 1.80, Molybdenum .25.

Most modern "stainless" steel firearms are manufactured from type 410 steel. Additives (again aproximate) in 410 are Carbon .15 max, Manganese 1.00 max, Phosphorus .04 max, Sulphur .03 Max, Silicon 1.00 max, Chromium 11.5-13.5.

The term "stainless" is relative. Stainless steels are usually many times more resistive to corroding agents, generaly their corrosion resistance is porportional to the relative Chromium content.

Stainless is primarily used in the food industry; many food stuffs contain agents that attack carbon steels. Much used in the aircraft industry where corrosion resistance at elevated temperatures is desired. Stainless has considerably lower yield strength than carbon steel but it retains it's original strength to higher temperatures.

Stainless has many decorative uses due to it's lack of need for protective finishes.

In most applications the sacrifice of strength for corrosion resistance is a worthwhile trade off for the end user.

With proper care, blued steel gun should outlast stainless gun. Not counting wear of the external finish on blued gun.

Sam
 
Back
Top