I do not think I could say it better than Julia Cochrane did (check out her Dejanews archive, julia.cochrane@iint.com , great writing).
------------------
> These people asking that only the military and the police have guns
> have no idea what they are asking for. Once the people are
> disarmed they will show you what police/military power is
> all about. You think things like what is going on in Bosnia,
> Haiti and other places can't happen here? You better think
> again. Once the people are disarmed it's too late. You cannot
> go back.
>
I think many of them know what they're asking for---they want government
to make people different from them pipe down and conform, and they
particularly tend to want "redistribution" of wealth in a continuing
stream from the people who create a great deal of wealth (like, say,
Bill Gates) or who just create enough wealth to be very comfortable
instead of just scraping by (like, say, me and James) to themselves.
And of course the demagogues are content to push for it on the condition
that they get to be in the catbird seat administering it all.
I don't think they realize what they're likely to actually get, instead
of what they want, should they "succeed" in the political arena:
1) A bloody civil war followed by
2) Either defeat and disenfranchisement OR a pyrrhic victory followed
by a totally trashed economy.
Gun owners are more educated and more affluent, as a group, than non
gun owners. The same attraction to finely crafted precision machinery
and action and labwork (reloading) and mathematical analysis (ballistics)
that drives people to become shooting enthusiasts is what makes engineers
and other members of the technoscenti. We are the engine of their
"boom economy" and if they provoke us to war, even if they win, they
lose, because the economic train won't run for anybody without the engine.
Non serviam, you statist bastards.
On the other hand, if enough folks accede to the very reasonable
demand of we lovers of liberty to be let alone, particularly as
regards the rest of the Bill of Rights and our guns, in the interests
of avoiding a really nasty civil war we'll probably continue to let
them sponge off us a bit (though even that has limits!) without
doing much more than bitching and moaning about it.
I think they do know what they're asking for. I just don't think
they've realized what they stand to lose if they push it to a fight.
Right now they're on the gravy train, getting far more from what they
tell Uncle Sugar to steal from us than they pay in. If they force a
fight, that gravy train stops. Dead. One way or the other.
Permanently.
-----------------------------
Personally, I do not expect much to happen. I may be a pessemist, but I have seen what even the inept Soviets got "accomplished", and I do not expect the US thugs to be any less efficient or ruthless. On the plus side, more people here still remember what freedom can be.
------------------
If you believe in freedom and means of protecting it...you might be a gun nut.
http://ddb.com/RKBA