Walther P99 range report

Rickmeister

New member
I mentioned in a post, a few weeks back, that I had bought a new P99.

I should remind you that I got swindled, at first, into buying the S&W half-breed (I foolishly ignored the lack of German proofmarks on it, duhhh); but I quickly had it exchanged for the real thing when I found out what it was---or rather wasn't. Then, with my all Deutsche 9mm issue, I went to the range for a complete shakedown.

My jaw dropped loose and swung idly on its hinges when I saw my targets after the initial sixteen rounds (yeah, I got the hi-cap). This gun is horribly beautiful, if that makes any sense. At 15 yards I had neat little 1" groups: a tightness I have never consistently achieved at that distance with either my Glock 17 or my CZ-75 PCR, my only other 9mms.

Only my Kimber Gold Match---and, ironically, my Bersa Thunder (yes, you read that right)---can rival that kind of result. But then those guns are in a separate league altogether.

True, the look and feel of the P99 has earned it all sorts of reviews, both good and bad; but cosmetics and ergonomics played little role in my decision to buy it (Although I personally find its reptilian look menacing in an attractive sort of way. Kinda reminds me of that time, as a kid, when I held a baby alligator :).) Ok, maybe the ergonomics part can be mulled over by anal-compulsive performance geeks. But the bottom line (no pun intended) is that this gun is adaptable to even those who would insist on having a different grip. Walther includes three interchangeable backstraps with this gun, so getting the right hold is really not an issue.

Taking it apart and cleaning it is every bit as simple as a Glock, too, and requires no special instruments (except for the striker assembly, which needs a flat-nose punch to open, if one chooses to be that meticulous.).

And then there's the ambidextrous mag release. Better than a USP's, and very convenient in almost any tactical situation that comes to mind.

Finally, it is narrow enough to comfortably carry concealed. Even in an IWB, if you're slender enough in those parts :D. Try that with a USP or Beretta 92/96.

So, my verdict is that the P99 is a fabulous gun for its price. It's a fabulous gun, PERIOD! In fact, I would choose it any day over the USP-9 and USP-40, and even the USP-45 if the P99 came in that caliber (maybe it will). It's a great deal-----as good if not better than almost any other gun in its class. Everybody ought to have at least one in their collection.
 
Last edited:
Rickmeister,

I also have four P99's, three 9mmx19's and one .40S&W and love each and every one.
The oldest 9mmx19, an Alexandria, VA import, is my favorite I think.
I'm glad you learned what the rest of us P99 owners already know and other shooters should give themselves the chance to find out! :D
The Walther P99 is a great pistol! ;)
If you want another Walther treat, get yourself a P5 or P5C. I just finished a deal on a P5C to go with my P5. :D
 
As one of the 40 owners from 1999, I can assure you that my gun has only failed to feed 3 times after the first range trip- once I learned how to fire the gun. These 3 times were commercial reloads.

I love it, and it is my daily carry gun. There is one thing more beautiful than a P99 brand new, that is one like mine with hoster wear and some scratches on the slide from dropping...

Other threads.
 
Rickmeister, congrats on the awesome new gun! I have a blue 9mm myself. Be careful now, you will soon be looking into buying a P88(got one two weeks ago) and a P5/P5c or both(I'm working on it). I still need to buy at least one more P99 and the new subcompact when it arrives.

Blades, I just received some 15 rnd Turkish P99 mags for $70 a pop free shipping. Look in the buy sell trade forum for a post by a fellow named Robert Johnson. Mags were brand new and work flawlessly.
 
Incursion, the post states 16 rnd but the ones I received have count holes that say 15, and that is all I can get into them. So, I'm assuming that they are the Turkish ones.
 
Absolutely, they are genuine Walther/MecGar mags. Took them apart and compared them. They only difference is the lack of the 16th witness hole.

James
 
Are they trustworthy enough for home defense or carry?
The gun or the mags? The gun, yes. The mags? I have a Mec-Gar 16 rnd hicap, along with two standard 10 rnd mags (made in Italy) that came with the gun. None of them have malfunctioned as of this writing.
 
The ONLY thing that I found amiss with mine was a chalky trigger pull at first. But a drop of Hoppe's #9 between the connector rod and the trigger latch did the trick. Now it's as smooth as vaseline on a baby's butt.
 
Back
Top