Walther P88

schild

New member
I saw all the P88 replies in the wundernine poll, I've never seen one in person much less held one. How is the grip size?, ergonomics?, any lefties own one? I've been tempted to get one from Earl, but hate to buy a gun I've never held. Please give me some P88 insight. Thanks
 
Last edited:
The P88 is a NICE pistol. It's a full size and the grip falls between the BHP and Beretta 92fs. It feels similar, but "fatter" than the the BHP but is nowhere near the size of the 92fs. It grips well, and if you have a big hand, you'll like it. It points naturally and has excellent balance.

I'm a lefty. The P88 is fully ambidextrous. The slide release also acts as a decocker. Ironically, even though the mag release works both ways, I still use my trigger finger to release the mag, like I've been doing for 30 years.

The P88 is very accurate. It's reputed to be the most accurate production pistol ever. I would dispute that, however. In my hands anyway, my P88 is slightly less accurate than my 1911's, but more so than my all my pistols. I enjoy shooting it. As much as I do, I hate to clean it! It has an external trigger connector bar ala 92fs. That, along with the dual controls, make it a pain in the a$$ to clean. One of life's little crosses I guess.

There is also a P88 Compact. IT IS NOT THE SAME! Unlike compact versions of other pistols, the P88 Compact's controls are completely different from the P88's, making it, for all intents and purposes, a totally new and different pistol. I've seen and held a Compact, but never fired one, so I won't comment on it one way or the other.

The P88 is an extremely high quality pistol. The workmanship and attention to detail is amazing. It is also relatively rare. This exclusivity comes at a cost. Expect to pay $1000+ for a P88 or $750+ for a Compact. Spare mags, (if you can find 'em), are $100+. What you get for $1K is German craftmanship at it finest. You will also, probably, be the only person at your range with one. Speaking fo myself, I enjoy that.

If you can swing it, you won't be disappointed.
 
I have looked at but not owned one. After close study, I bought a CZ75. The P88 was nicer made, but the butt is so broad over the double column magazine AND the ambidextrous multifunction levers that it was not comfortable in my medium-small hand.

The P88 Compact went back to the old Walther safety/decocker on the slide. Not as convenient, but it let them make the grip smaller and more comfortable. If our rulers trusted us commoners with normal capacity magazines, I would be interested in a P88C. It is not very compact, though, only a couple of rounds shorter in the grip and slightly shorter barrel.
 
For me, the gun feel very good except at the top rear of the grip where the web of your hand would be. It is just a tad wide for my taste, but not bad enough to sell off the gun.
 
I was interested in a P88 Compact before I got my P99. I held one but the grip was too fat for me. The pistol was rock-solid, and it should be perfect for anyone with larger hands.
 
FWIW, I own both a P99 and a P88c. Don't make me choose which is better.........I can't. Fortunely, I don't have to. I enjoy shooting both, but the P88c seems to be more accurate and have a smoother more sensitive trigger. The P99 feels a touch better in my hand, and lighter. The P88c feels a bit more solid, but I tend to feel the recoil more. Probably due to ergonomics. The P88 full size is just too big for my hand.

If memory serves, I picked up my P99 in .40 for $469, and in 9mm for $499. My local gunshop received a NIB P88c in that came in with only 1 10 round mag. I feel like I stole it for $439, then picked up some hi-caps for $70 a piece.

My only suggestion would be to try a P88 or P88c for fit. For quality and accuracy, you won't be sorry with either.
 
Big Iron

A NIB P88c for $439???!!!! :eek: That's an incredibly good deal. The one I looked at was used, had 1 mag, and was $750. I also saw a full-sized at another show, also used, for around $1,200. I didn't handle the full-sized as I wanted a smaller gun for carry.
 
I double checked my records, and I lied a bit. :o $439 for my P99 in .40, $469 for my P99 in 9mm and $499 for my P88c. I'm still happy, but just a bit confused and forgetful. Just for the record, I also picked up a VERY nice P4 for $276. This was about a year ago, and the prices on Walthers have increased a bit. Went in the other day, and the price on a P88c was right at $800 I believe. Just happened to be in the right place at the right time.
 
This is my most favorite Walther Pistol. It is awesome! I've heard that only the SIG P210 beats it in accuracy, but the P88 comes with high caps :D

tnl_136479_newp88.jpg


P99
 
I'm curious about the width on the grip of the P88. What does smaller hands mean? With my P99 I use the smallest insert, I would assume the P88 would be too big for my hands?:confused:
 
"With my P99 I use the smallest insert, I would assume the P88 would be too big for my hands?"

IMO, probably. I use the medium insert on the P99 and the P88's grip is just wide enough at the top that I can only actuate the trigger (in double action mode) with more of the pad of my finger as opposed to the joint. For me it's not too big of a deal as the DA trigger weight is not heavy.
 
Have a relatively new P88c and love it. But then again I love my BHP's too! The berreta 92 series I can handle, but they feel big in my hands - so I MUCH prefer BHP's, 1911A1's and the P88c. My P88c shoots very accurately (but no more so than my BHP's - well ok, my 2 custom BHP's anyway). I've heard 2nd/3rd hand that P88's might be a little "feed" sensitive with some JHP's (and maybe Earl's can provide some info - they recommended to me winchester JHP's). However, I;ve shot the below listed rounds so far with no issue: (but I've also dremel polished the feed ramp too)

- gold dot 124gr JHP
- hydra shok 124gr JHP
- am eagle 115gr FMJ
- win 115gr FMJ
- win 115gr JHP

DO NTO USE SILVER BEAR JHP'S THOUGH, THEY JAMMED BOTH THE P88C AND MY BHP'S!!
 
My experience has been the same as GWC. I've shot the exact same ammo as he has, plus some S&B JHP. I've had NO feeding or ejection problems with my P88c or P99.

As far as the small hands issue, I too have small hands. I've held, but not fired, a P88, and it felt uncomfortably large in my hand. I use the small backstrap in my P99 and it feels comfortable. The P88c feels about the same size wise to me, albeit a different feel. Don't ask me why, but I actually prefer to shoot the P88c just slightly over the P99. Sounds stupid considering the P99 might be a touch more comfortable in my hand. It could be partly because I'm a bit more accurate with the P88c.

I hope I never have to chose between them though. The decision might push me over the edge and they'd have to put me away.
 
Back
Top