Walnut tumbling media is terrible!

M

Machineguntony

New member
About three months ago, I bought a big bag of walnut tumbling media from Harbor Freight. I started experiencing all sorts of problems in all my progressive reloaders.

The problem comes from the walnut being hard and inflexible, so the brass has a problem not feeding into the shell plate or not aligning properly. The brass would sometimes jam at the first station where the cases would feed into the plate, the brass would be off centered by a little bit for the priming station, the walnut would get caught up in the priming mechanism, etc.

I finally figured out what was wrong when one of my bullet feeders went down. Upon looking at the feeder, I saw a piece of walnut had gotten into the feeder and prevented the bullet from dropping.

It took me a while to figure out what was going on, and it was a frustrating three months. I finally switched back to corn cob media, which is flexible and gives way. Problems solved!

Anyone else experience similar problems with walnut tumbling media? It's the worst!
 
Having used Wall nut to clean my brass for a long time never a problem .
Never had any Wall nut in or on the case but all brass needs to be checked after cleaning . I have run my brass in a lot of different loaders .
 
Lizard Litter

Ground walnut from the local pet store works fine for me.
I get the occasional piece stuck in the flash hole but I inspect my cases pretty intensely.
 
P5 Guy:
I get the occasional piece stuck in the flash hole but I inspect my cases pretty intensely.
Click to expand...

Good reloading habits and practices call for inspecting the brass all along the path from cleaning/sizing to the final bullet seating. Cleaning media has a way of finding its way into all sorts of places. :)

Walnut media seems to be better for the tough jobs while the softer corn cob media is good for light cleaning and especially polishing.

Ron
 
Walnut tumbling media is terrible!
Click to expand...

I disagree. But, whatever floats your boat. That's why they sell different types and brands of media. And dies. And bullets. And powder. And....and....and....
 
higgite:
I disagree. But, whatever floats your boat. That's why they sell different types and brands of media. And dies. And bullets. And powder. And....and....and....
Click to expand...

Ain't America great? That's why I love this country, the freedom of choice (fifes and drums playing in the background). :)

Ron
 
Not all walnut media is equal. Perhaps the brand you bought is the issue.
I have been useing walnut fo 60+ years without any problems. I do inspect my brass after tumbling.
 
I disagree as well...I tumble and shoot about 25,000 rds a year...( all reloaded in a Dillon 650 with a case feeder ).../ ... regardless of what media you use, you need to inspect the cases after they are cleaned ...and make sure you get the media out of them, check for cracks, etc...

I don't think corn cob media does as good a job in cleaning ...I tried it once and dumped it and went back to walnut shells.
 
I believe sometimes when it comes down to tumbling media it becomes a matter of the grit or how course/fine the media is, be it corn cob, walnut or whatever. One day when at I think it was Pet Smart I grabbed a big bag of media. It is Kay-Kob Bedding and Liter, 100% pure corn cob. Been sitting on the front porch a few years now. The stuff is just to coarse to tumble my brass in. Maybe this thread will serve as a reminder to give the stuff to my neighbor to use as kitty liter. I sure have no use for the stuff. :(

Ron
 
Small batch stainless pin is a mess around the sink, draining water, ect.
It DOESN'T create dust, you don't have the cost of replacing walnut or cobb media, and there isn't anything to plug up the machines (provided you use magnetic pins and use a strong magnet to check cases BEFORE you feed the machines).

With steel pins/water, you get brass that is spotlessly clean INSIDE as well as outside.
The tumblers (not vibratory) aren't particularly cheap for a good one, but they usually last the home reloader a lifetime.
 
Lets see, you are allowing tumbling media to get into your reloading machinery, and blaming the MEDIA???

I'd say there was something wrong with both your process, AND your analysis.

Looks to me to be a good example of why we inspect tumbled cases and remove all media (including dust if any) BEFORE they go into the reloading machinery, and what can happen if you don't.
 
I know corn cob can get stuck in flash holes. The walnut I used in the past was almost like a fine powder, no way it could get stuck. I think you might have bought the wrong type. I'm guessing harbor frieght only carries one type. Check out Graingers, I bet you'll find a finer grain.
 
wall nuts

Don't go cheap.

As others have said, you must constantly inspect your brass as well as your entire reloading process. Remember, you are making ammunition.

Curious: How many clean their brass prior to resizing and how many clean their brass after resizing?
 
My first step is to throw everything in the tumbler with walnut (I strictly use Lyman brand) and let it run about 2-4 hrs.

I then do all brass prep (size, deprime, trim, etc).

Then I tumble with corn cob (Lyman brand also) about another 2-4 hrs. to remove all the lube & other stuff.

After that it is load time.

When I process my brass, it is usually 600-1200 pieces at a time. My tumbler can hold 1000 30-06 size cases and I have done 1500 9mm at a time.

This has been my routine since I got my big tumbler on or around 1976.

Even though it works for some, I don't use pet store or cheap tool store media.

My tumbler holds around 32-35 lbs of media.
 
I thoroughly enjoy these discussions.

That said, let's remember this guy knows how to reload and has been reloading without problems for quite some time. He switched to a new tumbling media and has encountered problems that he traced back to the walnut media.

Simple fix, he's going back to corn cob.

I'm not sure the OP needs to be told how to reload. He's already got a system that works.

I appreciate all the comments because it might teach me something new or make me reevaluate MY procedure.

Disclaimer: I got started with corncob, it worked and I never tried anything else. (Note that this is not (necessarily) a good thing---I've said it before there's lots of reloading stuff I was totally unaware of until I started reading this site.)
 
OK,
'An Experienced Reloader' might benefit from what others have done...

Use a 'Tumbler' separator, banging around a little helps knock loose stuck media.

Dump cases into a big towel, pinch the ends shut and shake around, removes dust from the outside of the cases and gives cases a little more banging to get the last of that media removed.
 
Use a 'Tumbler' separator, banging around a little helps knock loose stuck media.

Dump cases into a big towel, pinch the ends shut and shake around, removes dust from the outside of the cases and gives cases a little more banging to get the last of that media removed.
Click to expand...

This ^^^ is what I do, too. Work the towel back and forth like polishing a bowling ball. Just be sure to wash the towel when the brass starts coming out dustier than when it went in. ;)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top