Violence Policy Center Report On Women and Handguns

papercut

New member
(With apologies if this has already been posted)

This news wire was found at http://www.usnewswire.com/topnews/Current_Releases/0131-119.html

Violence Policy Center Report On Women and Handguns
U.S. Newswire
31 Jan 13:53

VPC Report: For Every Time a Woman Uses a Handgun to Kill in Self-Defense, 101 Women Die in Handgun Murders

To: National Desk
Contact: Naomi Seligman of the Violence Policy Center,
202-822-8200, ext. 105

WASHINGTON, Jan. 31 /U.S. Newswire/ -- The following was released
today by the Violence Policy Center:

-- For Every Time a Woman Uses a Handgun to Kill in Self-Defense, 101 Women Die in Handgun Murders, New VPC Report Finds

-- Only Eight States Report Women Using Handguns to Kill in
Self-Defense in 1998

In 1998, for every time a women used a handgun in the United
States to kill in self-defense, 101 women died in handgun homicides, according to a new VPC report, "A Deadly Myth: Women, Handguns, and Self-Defense." The VPC report analyzes unpublished Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Supplementary Homicide Report (SHR) data.

VPC Health Policy Analyst and study author Karen Brock, MPH,
states, "In the wake of slumping sales to their primary market of white males, the handgun industry has set its sights on American women. In arguing that handguns are effective self-defense tools for women, the industry has focused on the threat of stranger attack. This message -- seen in gun industry advertising and repeated by firearm advocates in pro-gun publications -- is presented as an article of faith by the gun lobby. Yet the exact opposite is true. Handguns don't offer women protection, they guarantee peril. And the greatest threat to a women is the men she knows best: husbands, friends, and lovers."

According to the VPC analysis of the FBI data, a woman is far more likely to be the victim of a handgun homicide than to use a handgun in a justifiable homicide. In 1998, handguns were used to murder 1,209 women. That same year, 12 women used handguns to kill in self-defense. And when a woman does use a handgun to kill in self-defense, it is usually against someone she knows, not a stranger. Of the 12 handgun self-defense killings by women reported to the FBI in 1998, eight of the attackers were known to the women, while only four of the attackers were strangers.

According to the report, of the 47 states reporting SHR data to the FBI in 1998 only the states of California, Colorado, Georgia, Michigan, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Tennessee, and Texas reported incidents of women using handguns to kill in self-defense. In each state, the number of women murdered with handguns outnumbered the number of women who used a handgun to kill in self-defense. (See the chart for the number of women killed with handguns in these eight states compared to: women who used handguns in self-defense to kill a stranger; intimate acquaintance (spouse, common-law spouse,
ex-spouse, or boyfriend); or, friend or acquaintance.)

Number of Women Who Used a Handgun ...

Code:
    ......to
kill a ..... to kill an ............ to kill a friend
    ....stranger
in ..... intimate acquaintance.. or acquaintance
    ....self-defense
.... in self-defense........ in self-defense
California ..... 2 ..........
1 ................. 0
Colorado ....... 0 ..........
1 ................. 0
Georgia ........ 1 ..........
0 ................. 0
Michigan ....... 0 ..........
0 ................. 1
North Carolina . 1 ..........
0 ................. 0
Oklahoma ....... 0 ..........
1 ................. 0
Tennessee ...... 0 ..........
2 ................. 0
Texas .......... 0 ..........
1 ................. 1

Number of Women Murdered with a Handgun

Code:
California ..... 178
Colorado ....... 21
Georgia ........ 46
Michigan ....... 41
North Carolina . 59
Oklahoma ....... 20
Tennessee ...... 34
Texas .......... 124

The study also reports that in spite of gun industry marketing efforts, handgun ownership among women remains rare, with no statistically significant change since the 1980s.
------
A Deadly Myth: Women, Handguns, and Self-Defense will be available on the VPC's Web site today at http://www.vpc.org.
The Violence Policy Center is a national non-profit educational organization working to reduce gun death and injury in America.
 
KEYWORDS:
POLICY, WOMEN, GUNS
-0-
/U.S. Newswire 202-347-2770/
01/31 13:53
Copyright 2001, U.S. Newswire

Notice the sleight-of-hand the VPC pulls with the numbers: "In each state, the number of women murdered with handguns outnumbered the number of women who used a handgun to kill in self-defense."

The problem with VPC's report is that most women don't have to kill the attacker to avoid being a victim!

Excuse me folks while I go vomit.
pukeface.gif
 
No, the problem with their report was not the fact that defense may not mean a death. . . .

The problem was they correlated two different things, in such a way that the non-critical reader will assume that those 100 women died trying to defend themselves. After all, they ARE trying to dissuade women from defending themselves with a gun, the sleight-of-hand is throwing one defense vs. 100 people murdered.

This statistic reflects (amongst other things) the extremely low number of women who carry guns - not a consideration for an individual who is considering that as a means of self defense.

Of course, most people are idiots.


Battler.
 
Since when...

did I believe what VPC or HCI says?? The really sad thing about this is that people will believe it without doing any other research.

I think Tommy Lee Jones had it right in "Men in Black"; A person can be intelligent, well versed, and have valid opinions. PEOPLE are stupid, crowd-following herd animals, (pardon the paraphrase).

Makes me want to go out and buy another addition to the collection.

Regards,
S.
 
This is a case of intent:

Woman victem of murder. The intent was to kill her.

Woman used tool to fend of rape/murder. The intent was to escape.

No $h!T there are less killings as a result of a defensive use compated to offensive use.

What they are trying to say in their study is that Baltimore's Defense sucks because they didn't score as many touchdowns as Baltimore's Offense in the recent Super Bowl.

Good, God... those people will say anything won't they?
 
"In each state, the number of women murdered with handguns outnumbered the number of women who used a handgun to kill in self-defense."

Well, *sigh*, I guess I'll turn in my pistol and be a good little victim, because some idiots figure the ratio of women murdered to the number who protect themselves nullifies the right to defend myself.

NOT.
 
Back
Top