This is exactly what i did in the first place. Bought a big box of walnut, and a box of cob, and they weren't quite so expensive, more like ten. a few more dollars for a bottle of brass polish media treatment. Add the dope to the cob as you shake it, dry it, and turn the brass in. No need for hours of work, mostly an hour or so, and when the stuff gets filthy, or it takes more than a few hours, dump it and add another two dollars worth of media.
But, as I mentioned before, if a person washes off the soot, grease, dust, and other gunk that will come of with soap and water, that is the biggest half of the battle. Don't "clean" your brass in a tumbler, clean it in water, and use the tumbler to polish off tarnish, and prevent corrosion.
Just my two cents.