trade dilemma

[tacticalmedic]

I have a G-19 2nd generation up for trade, I have 1 guy who wants to trade me a Sig 228 and another guy who wants to trade me a Ruger Security Six Stainless .357. I really want both guns but I don't know which one to take. I have to make my decision TODAY. Which one should I choose and why?

 

[howwie]

I have no experience with either specific gun, but I'm pretty sure the SIG is a safe trade. (but I love my G19 !)

 

[skydiver3346]

Trade for Glock?

The Glock 19 is better than both of those in my opinion. However, if you must choose, I would select the Ruger .357 mag as you can shoot .38's and .357 magnums in same gun. Plus, it is a very dependable and safe firearm (just like the Glock).

 

[goodspeed(TPF)]

Iffin the Sig is in as good of condition as your G19 then it has more "dollar value". I'd keep the Glock.

 

[Wishoot]

That Security Six is a mighty nice shooter. But then so is the Glock.

 

[troy_mclure]

either would be better than the glock!

 

[tacticalmedic]

Thanks for your in put guys! I still haven't made my decision but I will post pictures of what I get.

 

[Ala Dan]

Both great firearms; but if you must, take the SIG~!

You will be well pleased~!

 

[chris in va]

We can't make that decision for you. Both are an equal (if not better) trade.

 

[scorpion_tyr]

Sig.

 

[BigJimP]

It depends on condition - but I think the Sig is a better gun than the Glock / but it depends on what you want .

 

[yamaha24]

sig

 

[MLeake]

What will be your intended purpose for the gun?

If you want a CCW, the SIG P228 is the better choice. The Security Six is a sturdy revolver, but not so easy to conceal (which is why Ruger made the Speed Six back when they made the Security Six).

If you want a woods gun, the Ruger is the better choice.

Have you ever shot a SIG? I prefer their shooting characteristics to those of the Glock, but many people feel just the opposite.

 

[Larry D.]

Ruger.

 

[Dr Raoul Duke]

I'd either keep the Glock or trade for the Ruger .357.

Dr. Raoul Duke
Gonzo Forever

 

[JWT]

Depends upon which you want more - a revolver or a semi auto. Both would be very good trades. I'd go for the Sig unless you want / need a revolver.

 

[comn-cents]

Go Sig. You can pick up the Ruger for pretty cheap.

 

[Chesster]

I prefer the 2nd gen G19. Of the two for trade, I'd go for the Sig 228.

 

[xdtactical]

I dont know why this guy would trade a 228 for a Glock . I wouldnt sell or trade my 228 for anything

 

[tacticalmedic]

Thanks for all the replies. I ended up not trading for the Sig and I am buying the Ruger.