This REALLY burns me up

invention_45

New member
Here's part of the story (it's long, so I only grabbed part of it. I'm sure it's been reported in other places in its entirety).


"

SARASOTA, Fla. (AP) -- A weeping Joseph Smith apologized Tuesday for the abduction, rape and murder of 11-year-old Carlie Brucia two years ago, telling a judge he had taken large amounts of cocaine and heroin that day trying to kill himself.

Smith told Circuit Judge Andrew Owens, who will sentence Smith to death or life in prison, that "I do not ask for mercy for myself. The only thing I can see to give me a life sentence is for the sake of my family. I do not want to see my children hurt any further."

Carlie's February 2004 abduction drew nationwide attention because it was caught by a car wash surveillance camera and subsequently aired on TV. Smith, 39, was convicted in November. Friends and even Smith's brother said they recognized him on the video as the burly man in a mechanic's uniform grabbing the young girl's wrist as she walked home from a friend's house on Feb. 1, 2004.

Jurors recommended by a 10-2 vote that Smith be executed. Owens, under Florida law, must give "great weight" to the jury's recommendation when he sentences Smith on March 15.

Smith told Owens he had been a heroin addict since he was 19 and had unsuccessfully tried to quit several times. He said his wife had kicked him out of their home in January 2004 and he had lost his job. He said he took drugs trying to overdose and doesn't recall much of what happened the night he abducted Carlie.

"I lost my business, my family and my self-control," he said, as his mother, Patricia Davis, also wept in the courtroom gallery. "My world was really coming apart fast."

However, he said, "I take responsibility of my crimes. I don't understand how this could have happened.

"

What does this boil down to ?

A G.D. violent CRIMINAL wants to "accept responsibility" (but blame drugs at the same time) not for himself, no. For his Family.

What did he get, a PR consultant? The only cliche' he didn't use was "I found the Lord".

Hello. Drugs did not kill Carlie. OWENS killed Carlie. Now Owens wants us to all think drugs made him do it. The excuse is stupid and invalid on its face. If he had robbed her, then it would at least sound like a plausible story (but he STILL would be responsible, NOT drugs).

First you abduct (and, presumably kill) an 11 year old girl. There's death penalty material if I ever saw it. Then you blame drugs, providing fodder for keeping "criminals" without victims in jail, instead of TRULY accepting the blame yourself. That's worth a 2nd death penalty.

He takes responsibility, but he doesn't know how it happened.

If he "takes responsibility", he shouldn't be up there begging for life in place of death. Accept is accept.

What a despicable show he put on, tear-dabbing and all.

What if, instead of trying to overdose on heroin and cocaine, he'd picked up a .357 and started trying to shoot himself but couldn't quite do it and missed, killing Carlie with an errant bullet?

Then he'd be blaming it on the gun. And we'd be hearing about that as a reason to ban them.

So let's use our heads, folks. De-fund Prohibition-II. Put the money into investigation of REAL crime with REAL victims and make the world a better place.
 
I've been under extreme amounts of pressure throughout my life and I never turned to alchohal or drugs. Smith sounds like he's going for the Twinky Defense. Smith made the choice to do drugs and therefore made the choice to rape and kill that girl.
 
I feel bad for his family who are also victims of his heinous crime, but he deserves the death penalty. He says he's thinking of them now. Did he think about his family, and for that matter Carlie's family, before commiting this horrendous act? The court should show mercy to his family by executing him quickly, and not allowing this to drag on for years and years.
 
garand shooter:

Funny you should say that. As I was watching the story on the evening news last night, I thought the same thing. Execute him and it's over for the family. Life without parole and they'll either have to visit him forever or explain to everybody why they don't want to.

For the family, indeed.
 
The use of drugs or alchohol in a murder is to deaden the soul and prime the nerves before you do the deed. When the soul wakes up from the drugs or booze (dry out) it brings out what you really did. That is what makes a junkie dangerous. Alot of people think they have control over their drug habit but this is what it leads to.

He has an evil heart and there is no place in society for him.

25
 
end prohibition and force criminals to face personal responsibility. Drugs didn't make him do anything, this person is a screwed up individual and that is why he uses and murdered. The drug use is only a symptom of the problem. This guy just got lit up, got horney, and decided to act on his impulses, period. People like him are not fit for any society and should be executed as quick and cheap as possible.

P.S. makes me sick to think of the hundreds of thousands of dollars we will be paying to keep him alive for the next 15 years until he's executed.
 
There are a few of us that think they should turn him over to a select group. Death is forever, but life in a private hell goes on forever. To bad there isn't a place to join that group of enforcers. My Dad used to say, "Take them into the woods. Nail their privates to a stump. If they can tear free, let them go!"
 
P.S. makes me sick to think of the hundreds of thousands of dollars we will be paying to keep him alive for the next 15 years until he's executed.

It's going to cost more for legal appeals than for keeping him clothed, sheltered, and barred (for life).

Something has got to give. Either remove the appeals process or the death penalty. I guess I lean toward removing the death penalty; but I make an emotional exception in this case.
 
Fisherman 66 said:

It's going to cost more for legal appeals than for keeping him clothed, sheltered, and barred (for life).

Something has got to give. Either remove the appeals process or the death penalty. I guess I lean toward removing the death penalty; but I make an emotional exception in this case.

These are astute observations. The problem is, we, as taxpayers, are now compensating lawyers to pursue this kind of B.S. at public expense.

The Bill of Rights says you have the right to an attorney. It doesn't say you are guaranteed to have the means to pay one. It says you have the right to engage one to represent you, if you can afford the expense. It certainly doesn't say I have to pay for your attorney, but that's what judicial rulings have established as case law.

I have long believed this country has got to stop paying for charity out of public money. That's what welfare is about. That's what medicaid and medicare are about. That's what guaranteeing flood insurance for people who build below sea level is about. And that's what paying for private lawyers out of public funds is about.

It's all wrong. And it has crippled the death penalty, distorted the free market for medical attention to the point many can't afford it out of pocket and encouraged people to build homes where no sensible person would put them.

Donning the Nomex suit now. . .
 
Give him a year on Death Row.

Put him in a cell. Provide a bucket with 364 inert & 1 live round. Greet him each morning, make him select one round each day. Load agun with the cartridge of his choice, put it to his head and pull the trigger.

If Smith has found the Lord, he wouldn't have to wait more than a year to meet Him.
 
You need a wheel gun for PHxdog's plan too. He needs to see the cylinder slowly rotate as the hammer draws back.

When he is judged guilty they should just have the balif (sp?) take him out back and shoot him.
 
Back
Top