I've gone through about a half dozen different .357 carbines, I guess it's been my 'thing'. Sold them all except my Handi rifle.
My Handi is about 15 years old and it's a real shooter. It's the old style with a 22" tapered barrel, open click adjustable sights and ejector (not the modern extractor). I mounted a Trijicon Reflex sight (battery free) on it to help out my old eyes.
With several loads it will shoot under 3" at 100 yards, and one or two will do under 2". It loves my 148 grain plated DEWC load, very quiet, very accurate.
The lever guns I've owned have been good, A Rossi Puma was a fine shooter, but didn't like .38's. Marlins have been good too, had an 1894 CP, a 16" ported barrel, no longer made that was very good as well.
.357 is an excellent carbine caliber. Some loads in a carbine are close to 30-30 ballistics. You can shoot .357's in a carbine all day long without a sore shoulder or ringing ears.