THE best semiauto shotgun?

Haha I love the threads with open-ended opinion questions...

I'm guessing you'll get quite a few responses for Beretta, slightly less for Remington, and the occasional vote for Benelli. Personally I'd say Benelli but it's just because they fit me like a glove.
 
If you never have to buy parts: Benelli M1. Awesome reliability, no need to ever clean anything other than the barrel.

If you have to be practical: Remington 1100/11-87
 
Based on what parameters / what do you want to use it for ???

There could be a dozen different answers ......based on what you want to do with it ......:confused:
 
I'm with BigJim, and others, on this: Give us some more parameters. For all we can tell, you want to know what's the best gun to survive being tossed into the bay after missing an easy shot.

RoscoeC said:
Winmossremchesteretta Silver Golden Diamond Luxe, Grade IV.
Roscoe, where you thinking of the Midas, Extra or Fine version? :D
 
Anybody make a semiauto this nice? :) You know, a double-deluxe-I've-got-way-too-much-money gun. I suppose Cosmi does.

But this was a gift to an American engineer in India.

www.drake.net/products/2?id=28637

"SOLD"

"Charlin, St. Etienne- 12 Ga. Sliding Breech Game Gun, ca. 1950-60 "

"Action spectacularly embellished with pink, green, and yellow gold fashioned in raised, highly sculpted inlays, flush inlays, and Ormolu (mercury gilding) background within the deeply chisled steel surface of the breech-opening lever. Exhibition grade straight grip stock and splinter forend with some of the finest checkering I have ever seen."

main.jpg
 
If you prefer gas operated, Beretta. If you prefer inertia operated, Benelli.

Both are equally good with different strong and weak points. I prefer Benelli simply because its strong points are more important to me
 
Lots of fine auto loading shotguns out there. For lots of different prices. In my zone I am extremely fond of the Remington 1100.
 
I sure like this one. I've only had it out a few times, but it feeds everything and I can shoot it all day w/o getting sore:

A400.jpg
 
best

Best. Yes....what about parameters? They've been asked for a couple of times and have not been forthcoming.
Most people who ask "best" questions seem to have a limited understanding of what is actually involved in an accurate answer. Asking "what is the best semi-auto that you have ever used?" is one thing. Asking "who makes the best semiauto shotgun ? " is quite another. An accurate answer would require the respondee to have used ALL semi-autos currently produced in order to know which one or which manufacturer is best. Even then parameters would be needed.
Pete
 
Back
Top