I haven't used that boot, but I can recommend the Original Swat 8" zipper design.
Working in the Armored car business keeps me on my feet and moving all day long. I walk over every imaginable flooring and in every conceivable type of weather. These boots beat my Hi-Tech's to shame and I couldn't be more satisfied.
In approximately 8 months since purchase, these babies show absolutely no sign of failure. The toes are a bit scuffed, but not a seam has popped and that zipper looks as good as new. For comfort and durability, these boots just can't be beat!