SW 15 or 28?

M

Mike19

New member
A LGS is selling 2 beautiful wood grip, 4" SW revolvers: a NIB Model 15 Classic (.38 Spl +P) for $850 and a used circa. 1983 Model 28 Highway Patrolman (.357 Mag) for $800.

If I can save the money I'm gonna get one of them, but which? :confused:

Need help deciding.
 
I like the 28 better, but prices are too high on both. A decent model 28 should be in the $500-$600 range. Not sure about the model 15.
 
I like the 28 better, but prices are too high on both. A decent model 28 should be in the $500-$600 range. Not sure about the model 15.
Click to expand...

Agree. A Model 28 in NIB condition, with box and papers...maybe...but a "classic" Model 15? No thanks. I'd just look for a older used Model 15 for about half that.

They're both nice guns. I shot the Model 15's I've had a lot more.
 
Not sure what prices are like by you, but both those guns are overpriced. Is the 28 Pinned & Recessed? By 1983 the 28-3s were being sold, and they are not, which brings downs the value. Is it a 6" or 4" barrel? 4" guns usually bring more money.

Assuming it is a ANIB 28-3 with a 4" barrel, top price would be $600 for a collector, but collectors want pinned and recessed guns and this one is not.


Is the Classic Model 15 a brand new gun of recent manufacture? If yes, listen to the earlier posts and find a good used one for $400-$450. The older, the better.
 
The Highway Patrolman's are high demand guns. Even if you find you don't like it (fat chance), you'd have no problem flipping it.
 
Fort Worth Texas paid 415.00 for a 28-2 from a pawnshop no less holster wear gun is tight like a bank vault. I'd say shop around man may run into something.
 
OP replies

Thanks for all your advice.

I have no dependents but I am retired so I can't afford both revolvers. Heck, I can't even afford one of them, but you only live once (I guess). So, I'll make like Broderick Crawford and go for the Highway Patrolman.

The Model 15 Classic is a currently produced model. S&W has a whole line of newly made "Classics". Check out their website.

I suspected the prices were way too high and I figured I'd get some comments on that. I do a lot of business with this LGS so I always get a 15% to 25% discount off his listed price.

I'm not familiar with the terms "pinned and recessed". I'll look them up.

Have a great day, ya'll. :)
 
"Pinned" is something S&W used to do with their barrels. After they were screwed on, a small pin was driven in to help hold them in place (as is my understanding). Stopped doing it in the early eighties(?), I believe I've read.
A little blurry, but you get the idea.
47285DAA-551C-4A03-B22D-BF9C1EC1609D-14333-00000B8825B9732C_zpsb1e49d42.jpg


"Recessed" is a ,well, recession around the chambers, so that the rim/case head is flush with the back of the cylinder. It is found only on magnums or .22s, at least on S&Ws. Have no idea if they still do this or not...
C605AC3D-0AAE-4FBD-BBB2-FDCAFFBC68D0-14333-00000B884DC58595_zps8625e66e.jpg


This is on my very own 28-2, as luck would have it. Here it is with my .38 M&P.
I have a new rear sight blade, before anyone points out that the current one is bent, just need to put it on...
F883329C-ECD3-4359-9EEA-F6720E01F940-17266-00000D88C9197899_zps8b231259.jpg
 
Last edited:
Neither. If NIB, the Model 15 Classic is probably about right price wise, but you can get used ones in the high $300 to mid $400s. The 28 is also high, especially since in 1983 it would not be pinned and recessed. I'd say low $500s tops on that particular gun.
 
$800 is way high for a Mod 28 unless it is unfired, in a wooden presentation box, with all the original do dads that came with the gun, and the papers. With the stock grips, and target sights.

If it is just in good shape with the orignal finish, with the stock grips. No box, no papers, or original cleaning stuff. It would go for maybe $450 is on the high end.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top