yournodaisy
New member
I know Uberti makes them both, but does one importer have a better finished product than the other? I was set on cimmaron, but found a stoeger locally, and I would rather buy locally then order.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Stoeger or cimmaron 1866 yellowboy
- Thread starter yournodaisy
- Start date
yournodaisy
New member
Thanks guys!
bedbugbilly
New member
T - I have no experience with the rifle you are asking about but I did just get done making a decision on what to buy in regards to Uberti, Cimarron or Taylor. I wanted a 4 3/4" .357 "Bisley". I talked with an experienced salesman at the gun shop where I have purchased a number of handguns from - they've been in business for probably 60+ years.
Anyway - I asked him in regards to Uberti, Cimarron or Taylor as I have often heard that Cimarron had a little bit better quality. They have had new guns come through their shop from all three places and his opinion was that "Uberti makes them all and I can't tell the difference other than perhaps a "special finish" that Cimarron or Taylor may offer from time to time as a "special finish".
I had to wait a couple weeks for the Bisley to come in and I picked it up the day before yesterday. It is absolutely beautiful. Great fit and finish, clean crisp lock up and trigger - I couldn't be happier and it's marked Stoeger on the barrel. I'm very happy that I had them order it from Uberti as it saved some $$ over what it would have been from the other two suppliers.
I'm currently shooting an Uberti 1851 Navy and it too, is a well made and very satisfying revolver to shoot. Personally, I'd have no problems with ordering from Uberti again - not saying the other suppliers aren't good as I'm sure they are but they were also priced higher and for me, I can't see paying more for the same thing.
Anyway - I asked him in regards to Uberti, Cimarron or Taylor as I have often heard that Cimarron had a little bit better quality. They have had new guns come through their shop from all three places and his opinion was that "Uberti makes them all and I can't tell the difference other than perhaps a "special finish" that Cimarron or Taylor may offer from time to time as a "special finish".
I had to wait a couple weeks for the Bisley to come in and I picked it up the day before yesterday. It is absolutely beautiful. Great fit and finish, clean crisp lock up and trigger - I couldn't be happier and it's marked Stoeger on the barrel. I'm very happy that I had them order it from Uberti as it saved some $$ over what it would have been from the other two suppliers.
I'm currently shooting an Uberti 1851 Navy and it too, is a well made and very satisfying revolver to shoot. Personally, I'd have no problems with ordering from Uberti again - not saying the other suppliers aren't good as I'm sure they are but they were also priced higher and for me, I can't see paying more for the same thing.