I live in N Va. Have owned both. Same price. Both had minor flaws I was unhappy with. Colt was a better shooter, but had a machinging cut on the slide that was a cosmetic flaw. Got rid of it. Springfield also had some slide cuts I was not pleased with. Also, the Springfield would not work with Wilson mags. So I got rid of it, too. In the future I will not order one, but one in stock at the gun shop, after a thorough inspection by yours truly. Bottom line: either one will please you if you get a good one. I tend to prefer the rounded main spring housing of the Springfield