I've owned both, but only keeped the P226 since I favor fullsize guns. It's a real tack driver. Also, the added velocity with the longer barrel is a plus, and follow-up shots "seem" quicker with it. Again, like the others have said, hicaps are plenty available (if your state allows it). If it's not for a CCW, or if the size of the 226 don't bother you, "IMO" it's a better choice.