lots of good books out there on SXS's vs over unders etc - but in general you will very few, if any, SXS's in sporting clays. SXS's are fun to shoot - but in sporting clays they'll be more of a novelty. But if you're really serious about a SXS - I'd suggest the Beretta. It's about $3,500 but its a lot more gun than either one you are looking at. The predominant gun in sporting clays is the over under - and you'll see a lot of Berettas, Brownings - some Krieghoff, Kolar etc but at most shoots the 2 B'Guns will probably make up 75% of the guns in the shoot ( in a variety of models ). A lot of the rest will be semi-autos Beretta, Benelli - etc but not too many Brownings. But what's popular isn't necessarily what is best for you. If you can find a "sponsor" or someone that will help you get into sporting - you will probably find they have some guns that they will let you try / or go to your local trap or skeet club and talk to some of the guys to see if they're shooting sporting and see what they're shooting. Personally I like the Browning XS Skeet - in a 12 or a 20ga for sporting - especially with a 30" barrel and an adj comb. I think the XS skeet model - because it has a paralell comb - is one of the most versatile guns they make. Personally I have it in 12, 20, 28 and .410 ( not tubed ) separate guns. I like them in the field - for skeet - and for sporting. About $ 2200 list - and a lot of gun for the money, but just my opinion. Good luck - and have fun with your selection process.