Semi-Auto or Pump

G

gdeal

New member
I'm sure a pump action shotgun is more common and there are some people out there that can do this action lightning fast. But for the common person, what is better for self-defense, a semi-auto or pump action shotgun?
 
Which is better 9mm or .45? Ford or Chevy? Beatles or Led Zepplin?

4.gif
 
I prefer an auto...most prefer pumps.

Good pumps are about a third of the cost of a good auto...which is part of the reason so many prefer pumps. Plus, a pump allows the operator to have more control of the firearm...for example, it is easier to chamber a round from the tube in an 870 than it is in a Benelli auto.

I terms of actually firing the shotgun in a defense mode, a pump forces the operator to be in 'deliberate control'...which is definitely a good thing.

Just my opinion...I'm sure you'll get a lot more.
 
Aw, come on...every one knows that 45 is better than 9mm, Ford is better than Chevy and Led Zeppelin is better than the Beatles. :D

Now...pump vs. auto...this one is tough!
 
I prefer an auto...most prefer pumps.

Good pumps are about a third of the cost of a good auto...which is part of the reason so many prefer pumps. Plus, a pump allows the operator to have more control of the firearm...for example, it is easier to chamber a round from the tube in an 870 than it is in a Benelli auto.

I terms of actually firing the shotgun in a defense mode, a pump forces the operator to be in 'deliberate control'...which is definitely a good thing.

Just my opinion...I'm sure you'll get a lot more.
Click to expand...
Good points all around.

I have a pump, but I think I would like an auto as well. Both are good.
 
In the hands of a truly competent shot gun handler of all types.... It is only a matter of personal preference... For every one else it comes down to what you are most proficient with. From field strip and cleaning skills on up to repeatable results from various positions and such. For me that is the pump... I have seen too many missed game kills due to a failure to cycle on the autos...
Brent
 
greyson, Having been a member under a month... YOU HAVE NO CLUE...:D You will see far more BADH (beat a dead horse) threads, get used to them and participate where you wish...
Brent
 
greyson, Having been a member under a month... YOU HAVE NO CLUE... You will see far more BADH (beat a dead horse) threads, get used to them and participate where you wish...
Brent
Click to expand...

so, what sort of stick do you recommend i get to beat the dead horse with? oak or hickory?
 
The pump is less expensive and they can be fired surprisingly fast. For me they offer a rythm with the pumping action that I think helps me shoot more accurately at moving targets, moreso than an auto does. It also gives you that pause that allows you to better re-assess your aim to ensure a better second shot if necessary.
Oh yeah, they aren't as ammo finicky and are usually more reliable and cleanliness isn't as big an issue.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top