Semi auto loose barrels?

P

Prof Young

New member
Gun smiths:

Went to a gun auction and handled a lot of semi auto hand guns at the preview. I noticed that on every one of them, with the magazine removed and the slide locked back . . . the barrel was loose and i could wiggle it around.
These were all used guns, but they were many good brands. Is this normal?

Live well, be safe
Prof Young
 
Hi. Perfectly normal with the slide open. The barrel on most pistols isn't 'locked' into the slide when the action is open.
A 1911 barrel, for example, is only 'locked' in the slide when the slide is closed. Have a look at this. The 'bands' on the top of the barrel mate with recesses in the slide and the pistol is locked into 'battery' only when the actionis closed. http://stevespages.com/ipb-colt-1911.html
Most pistols aren't a whole lot different. They can and do 'lock' differently though.
 
Thanks.

T.
Thanks for the info. It just surprised me. I only own one semi-auto and assumed the barrel had some wiggle room cause it's a very cheap gun.
Thanks again.
Prof Young
 
Well, it is normal for a locked breech pistol, where the barrel and slide are locked together until the bullet is out of or almost out of the barrel. But on a blowback pistol, a really loose barrel could be trouble, though some barrels that have to be removed for disassembly are a bit loose.

Examples: A 1911 barrel that is loose when the slide is open is perfectly normal. A Colt Model 1903 barrel is a little loose as it has to turn and unlock from the frame so the pistol can be taken down for cleaning. A Walther PP with a loose barrel indicates there is something wrong.

Jim
 
Lots to learn.

Jim:

I guess I don't know the difference between those two types of systems. There is a lot to learn. I guess I should find a book on hand guns or some such.
Thanks
Prof Young
 
The only thing that matters is play in the barrel/slide fit at full lockup at the front and rear of the barrel. Play between the slide and frame doesn't really hurt accuracy any but the barrel has to lock up snugly and in the same position every time it cycles.
 
Play between the slide and frame doesn't really hurt accuracy any but the barrel has to lock up snugly and in the same position every time it cycles.
Click to expand...

And in the 1911 design the barrel is still in contact with the slide stop pin.
The effect is not very large unless the play is excessive, but it shows at higher levels of Bullseye.
 
Yeah that is because they are recoil operated. When the slide comes forward it locks with the barrel and pushes it all the way forward. When the gun fires it recoils and the slide and barrel travel back together slightly and then unlock. This backwards travel of the barrel is why it wiggles when the gun is open.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top