I'm sorry that I don't know anything about the specifics of either model you're looking at, but I have a few opinions on gun safes having owned three of them thus far...
Fire-proofings and ratings just don't mean much, if anything to me. In my opinion, the kind of fire that is going to ruin guns is not going to be stopped by a safe and even if the flames are kept at bay, the heat will not be, or not for long and depending on the severity of the fire and the location of the safe, the following water damage is going to be just as ridiculous an assault. And as someone that has experienced home and house fires
eek
my best advice is to plan your entire life & world around AVOIDING them rather than hoping or expecting that your safe can fend off their attack.
Now, when I say that, I'm not trying to say "quit throwing lit matches in your living room and smoking crack in the bedroom"
, I'm talking about the less obvious things such as possible chimney fires, dryer vent fires, electrical wiring and the things that many folks aren't well aware of until they have some very specific reason to become aware of them.
My next thought about gun safes concerns
long guns and their propensity for just wrecking the real estate in gun safes.
I'm a handgun guy in a big way and I'm always going to be that way. Handguns are what I enjoy the most so
my safe exists for those and while some long guns make it in when I have the space, they are the first to get booted out when space is at a premium. I suggest a much lower cost metal gun locker or gun cabinet for long guns. If I'm spending $1200-$2500 on a safe, eating up my space with a Mossberg 500 or a run of the mill AR seems ludicrous to me. In that vein, a Liberty Fatboy Jr has been a
HEAP of safe for the money for my uses. It's got a lot of usable space for comparatively low money but it's not what a guy who wishes to protect a slew of long guns would want.
And you simply
must plan to bolt it down, no matter WHAT you buy. If it's not bolted down it's subject to attack and at the bare minimum, a threat will knock it over or tip it over even if they never get inside. Just consider for a second the idea of your favorite life-long firearms inside a huge metal box that's been knocked over by a thug.
So in your plans, know that you need it placed somewhere that you can secure it well.