Both guns are priced for $180 each. The Colt has a lot of bluing removed and some scratches(nothing deep). The Smith has some minor holster wear and it has adj. sights. The Colt has a better cylinder lock-up but no adj. sights. As far as the blueing on the Colt, I have no clue why some of it are gone, it sure doesn't look like holster marks. Maybe an aborted rebluing attempt? I want a revolver as a trail,hiking and tackle gun (a beater gun!). I think any of these 2 will fit the bill, I just need some input just to be sure before I let go of my hard earned money. BTW, the store/range owner will let me try 10rds for function testing. Thanks in advance!