S&W 686

Lots of variables. But the $600-700 range is pretty typical.

The 6" probably isn't in quite as high demand at the 4".
 
I disagree about the 4" being more in demand. I believe the 6" is more in demand and more popular all around. This isn't a carry gun per se. It's a hunting gun and hunters prefer the longer barrel.
 
Actually on the S&W forum

On the S&W forum the 3"-4" is a very sought after gun, especially the old ones and always sell quick for a good price. I have a 6" myself but wouldn't kick too much if I had to have a 4". I'd say the 6" is a tad nose heavy but the Pachmahr grips make it very easy to handle.
 
686's in 6" in my area ...are around $700 ( call it $600 - $800 if you want a range )....and the 4" will go for about $ 100 more in my area so $700 - $ 900 probably....
 
You might want to analyze the results on recent sells on GunBroker. As already stated, condition can make a big difference between a four hundred dollar revolver and an eight hundred dollar one.

I also agree with several others and think the 4" barrel is more desirable. Of course, there are not a lot of pistol hunters in my area.

Bias against the internal lock seems to be having a positive impact upon the price of earlier S&W revolvers. The price estimates by others in this thread is making me feel better and better about my latest Model 25 Mountain Gun purchase. :)
 
I have a 6" that's basically new, early 90's vintage. I doubt it's seen 20 shots. I have no intention of selling it though.
 
Around here, used 686's go for between $450 - $600 on the reasonable side. As far as barrel length, the general rule with S&W's is that of the normal production length barrels, 2.5" is the most valuable, 4" is in the middle, 6" is least valuable. The difference between 4" and 6" is usually around $50, but 2.5" guns, especially when you are talking about model 66's for example can get a $200 premium in some cases.

I am by no means an expert, just sharing my experience.
 
I have a 6" that's basically new, early 90's vintage. I doubt it's seen 20 shots. I have no intention of selling it though.
Click to expand...
That's a very nice revolver, I'd be happy to own & love it. I would submit that it's a full production gun and "early 90s" puts it -well- in to production by ~10 years. It's not rare, it's not specifically collectible.

If it were completely unfired, no handling marks, no cylinder drag line, with original box & accoutrements, the market could deem it "collectible", but if it's been shot & used a bit, I would say there's no reason not to shoot & enjoy it.

Unless you have a very similar revolver that you shoot regularly, it almost seems like you're cheating yourself out of this one if you don't get some trigger time with it.

Just my opinion, may not work for others.
 
Salmoneye said:
You left out the 8-3/8" barrel...

;-)
Click to expand...

I don't know, do you consider the 8-3/8" guns regular production? I wouldn't say they are as rare is 3" and 5", but not as common as 2.5", 4", and 6".

I would put 8-3/8" at more than 4" and less than 2.5" if I was pricing them.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top